Have you switched from an iPhone to Android?

dgdangel1

New member
I'm looking to make the switch from two iPhones on a family plan with AT&T to two Android phones on Verizon. Frankly, I love the iPhone and think it's an excellent device. Unfortunately, AT&T in my area isn't all that great. In most cases it's fine and I don't have any issues but inside my house it's like I'm in a dead zone. Considering our cell phones are our primary phones, making calls tends to be pretty important. Therefore, we're looking at switching.

That said, I'm kind of scared to make the switch. I really like my phone, when it's making calls of course. I'm nervous that the Android experience might not be what I have today and given how much it's going to cost to break my AT&T contract and purchase two phones (likely Incredible or X), I imagine you can understand why I'm a little hesitant.

As someone who has held an Android phone for about 10 minutes (the Eris I believe), I really don't know much about what I'd be getting. I don't understand the experience that an Android based phone provides. And for some reason, when I went into a local Verizon store, the guy acted like it was a good thing the Incredible was sold out for a month or so. Not only that, but there was no display model or anything for a prospective customer to try out, and yet, he cheerfully told me I couldn't get my hands on one for at least a month. I then asked him why he was so happy he wasn't going to be signing up a new Verizon customer that day. I think his perspective changed a little at that point.

Anyway, maybe I'm not asking a very good question here I suppose, but if anyone has any advice or knows where I can find more information on what a new user could expect, I'd greatly appreciate it.
 
I switched after 2 years with an iPhone 3G to the HTC Desire with Android 2.1

Ive had the phone nearly 2 Months now and apart from missing a few of the games i became adicted to on the iPhone, I havent looked back.

Android 2.1 is just as good as the iPhone OS, better at some things. There arent as many apps available, but I found free or cheap alternatives to all my essential iPhone apps on the android market, and many of those are better than the equivilents i had on the apple product.

The freedom of choice and the customisability of Android really appealed to me.
And the UI feels far more modern and sophisticated than the iPhone OS UI which really hasnt changed a lot since the 1st iPhone. The fact I have flash lite (soon full flash) and can fully multitask are also major factors that make android an obvious choice for me.

the one downside I have found is the fact you cant install apps to the sd card without rooting the phone, so you soon run out of app space, but this should soon be fixed with android 2.2 Froyo.

I havent found a single thing that i cant do on the Desire that i could on the iPhone 3G.
I'd say get your android phones, you wont regret it.
 
The incredible is basically a nexus one with a second led flash bulb and made out of plastic with a weird back cover instead of metal like the nexus one. It also runs htc's sense over android 2.1.

Android has come a long way from original release. It's now pretty attractive I think.

Pros to switching:
-Free google nav, perhaps the best navi out there.
-Open OS, no limitations on how you use it.
-Flash 10.1
-better notifications system than iphone
-incredible/droid x better spec wise in most ways compared to 3gs
-68K apps in the catalog, most of the major ones on iphone are on android too.

Cons:
-New iphone out, slightly better specs than anything else, though I expect that will change in 6 months or less.
-Iphone is simpler to use, android is geared at those more techy, although I think it's pretty simple and intuitive to use (much much better than blackberry for instance).
-Iphone has more apps and games.

What to expect:
You will need to play with the phone for a couple days to learn all the features. Shouldn't take longer than that if you are fairly familiar with computers/technology.
 
Hey Chris, nice to see ur thinking about moving on to better things

As an Android enthusiast, I can assure you that you'll find the switch to be well worth it. With Google behind you, there is rly nothing you can't do with an Android phone. Google Maps alone makes it worth it, especially the FREE turn-by-turn navigation that rivals all paid GPS units.

The other feature that makes Android stand out is Voice-to-text. Any app that has an input text field will allow you to turn speech into text. I do it when im driving and texting someone, although at that point its not texting because Im not typing, but you know what I mean. And with Froyo (the next Android Update, aka 2.2), which the Droid X will be getting by summers end, you have the option to unfilter curse words!! It works really well lol.

Another unique feature of Android is the Voice Search. Its undoubtedly one of the coolest features of the OS and you will use it ALL the time when you learn its power. To be able to say "Restaurants" and have it bring up a list of places near your location, or to say "Navigate to (your destination)" is like watching magic being performed before your eyes!

And lets not forget MULTITASKING!!! This rly needs no explanation, all opened apps run simultaneously. Nothing gets shut off when u switch apps. Of course iOS 4 comes to mind, but dont get me started on that. Everything it does Android ALREADY does. Verizon rly did get it right to market their Droid lineup as "Droid does".

There are currently two things that make me upset about the Android OS.
1) No support for animated gifs, which means if you rely on weather radars n such then you are kinda sol. HOWEVER Froyo WILL support animated gifs, so you will have to wait till the end of the summer when it releases for Droid X.
2) Small contact picture when making a call. Google only supports 96x96 px contact pictures. So even if you assign a high quality picture to a contact, it will shrink to that size when synced to ur gmail account. When making a call, the quality of the picture is horrendous, not to mention you have this tiny picture. It rly is embarrassing and has not been fixed since Android released in 08. Hopefully with Gingerbread (the update after Froyo) releasing Q4 they will fix it. That update is going to include a UI overhaul.

If you ever decide to root your phones, which is the equivalent of jailbreaking on the Iphone, then you will be introduced to what is undoubtedly the most loyal and enthusiastic community of any mobile OS platform! There are so many goodies that come with a rooted phone, such as custom themes and custom roms which add even more functionality to the Android OS. My suggestion is that once you become familiar with Android and feel like taking it to the next level, root your device and explore the wonderful world of custom roms!

As far as phones go, I would get the Droid X. Sure the Incredible is a great phone, but the Droid X is miles ahead of it, as much as it hurts me to say (im an HTC fan). The less a company customizes the Android OS to their liking, the faster it gets updated when Google releases their updates. The Incredible has Sense UI which, although was the king of Android custom UIs, is being overshadowed by the number of third party widgets/home replacements that once made it stand out. And like I stated before, the Droid X will get Froyo by summers end, which brings so many new things to Android like true Adobe Flash support, animated gifs, business features, a huge performance boost, using the camera flash while recording videos, and just so much more. HTC stated that Sense 2.2 will be available sometime this year but who knows when that will be.
Now lets look at it from a Rooted perspective. When rooted, you can load custom roms which I stated before. This means that developers can and will port over custom UIs, like Sense, to be used on non Sense devices. So think Sense UI on the Droid X. However, this does not work well unless the hardware is nearly identical, and even then its not a perfect port. However, it is super easy for developers to make a stock rom, aka vanilla rom, that will completely replace a custom UI, bringing it back to the default way that Google made it. This means that if you get an HTC phone with Sense UI, u will have the luxury of being able to have both HTC's custom UI AND the default, switching between the two whenever you want.

Software aside, there are the hardware differences which obviously cannot be updated. So that already makes the decision easier for you if you are concerned more about hardware capabilities than software.

And lets talk about carriers. The one advantage you had with the Iphone was that it was on ATT which is a GSM carrier (sim card based). This makes it easy to swap phones and use ur same sim card, and gives you the option of buying a local sim card based plan when u travel overseas. In addition, Verizon, being CDMA, does not allow you to use voice/data at the same time, which ATT does, as im sure u've heard in their commercials. Its one of the things preventing me from going to Verizon (with the other being their rediculous prices). Sprint is also CDMA, but with 4g you can do both when you are in a 4g area. The one downfall right now is that you have to pay a $10 premium on top of everything else when you buy a 4g phone, regardless if you have 4g in ur area or not. The HTC EVO 4g is an amazing phone, and you can go to a number of sites to look at a EVO vs Droid X comparison. The other 4g phone going to Sprint is the Samsung Galaxy S Pro which has a keyboard. And Tmobile, the carrier im on, has the Nexus One (my current phone) and is getting the Samsung Vibrant (our version of the Galaxy S) in July. Tmobile will have the fastest data speeds by the years end in part to their HSPA+ rollout, which is currently being deployed at a rapid rate across the country. They have to call it 3.5g, but dont let that fool you, it is faster than Sprint's 4g. In any case, u have options no matter which carrier you switch to.

There are so many advantages that Android offers over the Iphone that this post can go on for a while. I'd recommend you read up on any of the Android forums : Here at Android Community, Android and Me, Android Police, etc. And be sure to read up on rooting as well. If you are gonna stick with Verizon then you cant get either phone atm, so might as well get ur Android knowledge up!!!
 
Apple's pluses:
- Super simple to use
- Super clean UI
- Sync's well with MobileMe if you're an avid Apple user

Android's pluses:
- True multi-tasking, far superior to Apple's half-assed partial multi-tasking
- Fully customizable. Don't like the tray notification for a text message, you can use a pop up instead, etc
- Faster web browser than Apple's mobile version of Safari
- Widgets
- Carrier/Hardware Choice
- FREE syncing of Gmail/Contacts. Decide to wipe your phone? It'll load itself back up with your contacts. You can also access them online. All done via push. MobileMe != free.
- Google Navigation, which is free. It's awesome.
- Google Voice integration, free
- Most apps are free compared to the iPhone
- Wifi Tethering Built In
 
personally, i dropped my iphone 3g as soon as the g1 one came out... and never looked back. android has just been a better experience for me.
the fact i didnt have a company telling me i couldnt do anything.. has kept me with android really.
also... you can always crack the iphones and sell them. you'll make back most of the money you spent to switch if you do it quick lol.
 
Appreciate all of the feedback. I visited Best Buy this morning and put pre-orders on two Droid X phones. However, I have a feeling my wife will probably prefer something smaller like the Incredible. I will be selling my iPhone 3GS on eBay to recoup a lot of the costs of switching.

I spent some time in a Verizon store yesterday with the Incredible and truly, I enjoyed it, but I do prefer the experience of the iPhone OS. I suspect that will change as I become more comfortable with Android and know more of what it can do. I'm also a firm believer in innovation and as a developer myself, I know what kind of progress Google will make in a year, when Apple will likely have iPhone 5 only marginally better than the current phone. I'm a little uneasy about the fact you can't talk and surf on Verizon but hopefully that doesn't become an issue.

All in all, it will be nice to make reliable phone calls in my home again.
 
I think you'll realize quickly how limitless the OS is in comparison to Apple's iPhone OS. The #1 complaint I hear from converters is that the Android UI isn't as pretty. Google has come out and said the next major release will have a UI overhaul, so no worries.

The Incredible is a nice piece of hardware. The Droid X/EVO are too big for my tastes, but the N1 is perfect for me. It's nice to have choice sometimes
 
Absolutely agree. I hate that Apple, or Steve Jobs really, has so much control over what my phone can do. I'm looking forward to freedom and love the idea that my wife and I can have nice Android phones but have a choice over the models. Can't wait.
 
Hi. I read this thread with great interest, in fact I joined the boards just to comment as I am in a similar position. I have an iphone, mac computers, the whole deal but was really put off by Jobs response to the antenna problems on the new iphone 4(which I was recently very excited about). Now I am looking at the droid X and seeing which of my iphone apps are also on the android OS. My only concern is that the droid X will be obsolete before my 2yr contract would be up. With the iphone I could at least be guaranteed that Apple would support the iphone with iOS updates for those 2 years. In 2 years from now would my droid x phone be able to run android 2.5 (or whatever version is likely then)??
 
It will be able too but it won't get it. So far Verizon only supports their Android phones for a year or less. There's supposed to be some awesome dual core Android devices being released later this year. If you can, wait and get one of those.
 
Hi, I was in your shoe, until this morning. I had the original iPhone, and iPhone 3G (almost 2 years with that now). I was hoping to get the iPhone 4. Everything about it seems great. But there were 2 flaws that was a big no-no. It was the antenna around the iPhone 4 that if you hold the phone the way you normally do, you basically short circuit the antennas and the signal degrades quickly.

http://www.engadget.com/2010/06/25/hey-apple-youre-holding-it-wrong/?utm_source=twitterfeed&utm_medium=twitter

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4gb3aQ5XoQw
(And dozens other people's videos who report the same thing on youtube)

Another is the quality of the iPhone screen. They can advertise how many times stronger than whatever and comparable with some sapphire crystal, but real world testing says otherwise. The video below is a new iPhone 4, being dropped at normal holding-height. Let say you walk around checking your phone, you bump into someone and drop it... well, just watch the video.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K7-OBoDFeDY

So after a couple days of researching on the iPhone, the flaws are hardware-based. The only way they can fix it is to redesign it or you have to buy a case. But seriously, after 4 drops, the iPhone screen cracks? A free phone can do better than that!

This is my first post.

Anyway, I just signed up for Verizon Wireless (new customer), and I got the Motorola DROID. I'm loving it. Screen looks really nice, everything seems to respond and load faster than on the iPhone, particularly the browser, which is what I use the most on my phone.

It is scary to switch, because for the last 3 years I am used to the iPhone, and had the mindset of "owning the best", now I'm not so sure. The other thing is I don't like how Apple has a tight control on app approval, locking down their OS, and doesn't allow competition with anything Apple already put out.
 
So could I "root" the droid x or other android phone and install the latest os? I am not too familiar with rooting (I jailbreak my Iphone because I hate Apples tight grip on my user experience).

Parasol, I agree, it's a little scary leaving the apple comfort blanket and switching to something different. But as I said above, I want to define my user experience and not have it dictated to me by Herr Jobs which is why I always jailbreak and it seems I can do that with android.
There also seems to be a fresh problem with the new iphone 4's this morning regarding the proximity sensor doing all sorts of wacky things.
 
Back
Top