Harry Potter and The Half Blood Prince

In the books it's Snape meeting them. He also commnets on Tonk's changed patronus. Why do they have to change it? Is Tonks even in the film?

Poor Tonks getting killed by her cousin Bellatrix Lestrange. At least Molly Weasley finished her off. :D
 
Silly silly Lisa... will you ever ever learn, ACCIO LAPTOP! ;)

And a bit of Wingardium leviosa, controlling pebbles with my mind to tap the keys :)
 
Ah, I can see how you'd think that. I have read the books which makes most of the above sound confusing. I was just bored and rambling quite a bit :D:D

I suppose I mean speculate about how they're going to do the next few films, and what they're going to include etc.

Hope that makes at least a little bit more sense :p:p
 
That's stupid. They are the same story, the same spirit, told differently, for a different medium. They need to provide an experience apart from the books, so you don't even need to pick one of them up to get the story.
Not sure who said that (wasn't me though), but it's a tricky one. Of course they need to adhere to the core story and the characters (and not have, for example, Remus suddenly turn out to be a bad guy); but in a Hollywood movie there will have to be changes. Just putting everything from the book to screen will result in a film that's 6-8 hours long at LEAST. I agree with you that a lot of it is dumbed down, or aspects changed to the overall detriment of the story. I just don't agree with your statement that you can't judge the movies without reading the books. That's just silly, and should not be the case with any adaptation.
 
Well I haven't done anything wrong though :D I don't download thankyou very much! Although I did download Coldplays Violet Hill & Keanes new track because they were free ;)
 
I know :(

I just really cant understand why they would do that. Its such a fantastic scene and you have all these characters gathering...I mean RAB its Dumbledore..its a MAJOR you know what :(
 
Back
Top