Harry Potter and The Half Blood Prince

It does look fab doesn't it? :D

All spoilered just in case anyone is reading this who has just watched the films and not read the books.

Now I was 100% sure that Snape was not evil (I wont say good because he's so not good for what he did to Harry) after reading OotP. If he was evil, when Harry gave him the cryptic message 'he's got Padfoot at the place where it's hidden' Snape could have just pretended that he didn't have a clue what Harry was talking about and would have still saved face. However, at the end of HBP I was shocked as I was so sure Snape was on the good side but I read it a second time and realised that Dumbledore was probably pleading for Snape to kill him. So before DH I was absolutely certain that Snape wasn't evil until I actually read it and I kept changing my mind throughout the book (a testament to JKR's fantastic writing).
Anyway, my question is what did Snape say in the OotP film when confronted by Umbridge and did Harry give him the message? It's just I can't remember and I think that's an important point in the evil/not evil debate. If it was included then people may have made their minRAB up about Snape before watching the trailer.

As for the trailer it doesn't actually show
Snape killing Dumbledore so some people may just think Harry has finally cracked and lost it at Snape. Unlikely but you never know.
Are there many people who watch the films who haven't read the books? I know one of my frienRAB hasn't read them but I think she only bothers with the films because she gets dragged along :D
 
I wish they would not make the films PG's as the boooks get darker and darker so the tone of the film should reflect that. And PG does not.
 
Hey Cassie! :) There are more girls than guys on here I think :) Yay us!

awww...no you don't sound like a spoilt brat. Just a dedicated HP fan.....we like them on here!! :D:D

And,
 
Luna and Bella were definitely my favourites.

Anyone else think Luna could handle a who story herself, like post HP?

And did anyone else find themselves wishing HP dead? I cannot stand Daniel Radcliffe, he just really annoys me and whilst I found this film a vast improvement on the last one, I put that down to Luna, Bella, Ron, Hermione, Cormac, Snape, Malfoy, Dumbledore, McGonagle, Lavendar, Horace and Tom Riddle. I just found myself hoping that the "Twist thats not in the book" that I read about, would be Harry dying, he just really got on my nerves more so than any other film.

It wasn't like that in the books, I loved HP, now I think I'm going to hate him in the books aswell.
 
Back
Top