Guys, which girl sounds hotter (based on physical description)?

[Future Mrs. Pena]

Girl One:
- Five foot four
- Tan
- eyes that are so dark they look black
- really short black hair (like Mariska Hargitay on Law and Order SVU)
- really skinny (body like Kate Moss - not anorexic... natural body)

or

Girl Two:
- Five foot one
- Pale with a ton of freckles
- Golden-brown eyes
- Shoulder length brown hair with thick side bangs
- Skinny like girl one, but curvier (like Kourtney Kardashian before her baby)

So, physically, which girl would you go for and why?