Guns N' Roses (Yes and Chinese Democracy, so don't make other threads on it.)

But what about my claim to Back in Black?
You just skipped right over that didn't you now?
AND, if we're only comparing banRAB according to album sales then what about Fleetwood Mac with Rumours in 77'?
I'm pretty sure that sold way more than AFD.

Oh wait I was going to make another point.
If the double sided Pink Floyd album sold 11.5 million X 2 (counting as two sales) then it doesn't matter anyway lol.
It's the same artist, still sold more than any two Guns N Roses albums. :usehead:
 
If you listen to the solo material of the different merabers you can see why the result of them all coming together was so explosive. It also serves to emphasise why as soon as the original line-up began to split apart it was never as good again. By this I mean Appetite was the pinnacle, although to follow up and surpass perhaps the greatest record of all time was always going to be a virtual impossibility.
The solo work of the original merabers has merits, Duff's and Izzy's being the strongest, but Velvet Revolver never recaptured it, which just proves it was about unique chemistry between five eclectic talents in a specific time and place, ie the 80s LA rock scene.
 
i rewally hope the album never does get released because i only had to hear two of theyre new songs and its almost unlistenable
 
Wow! Really?! Isn't that what happens to people who are almost 50?!

Awww, isn't that sad? Someone doesn't remeraber the name to a song. Well, maybe Guns N' Roses should just quit while they're ahead, I mean selling close to 100 million recorRAB in only 6 years of being active isn't good enough...
 
Hooray for the annual 'Chinese Democracy is definetly coming out this year , honestly , no bull**** , this time it's really going to happen' thread
 
yea it's saying musics more than a one-horse race nowadays. Music's diversity is wide and varied, the fans are liking more different things nowadays. It still doesn't make them the greatest band ever, it just makes them the greatest band ever in your opinion. And THATS the truth ma soeur.
 
20060626_axlrose.jpeg


I`m assuming it was the fashion police
 
Whats more important than his rating is his reasoning for that rating.

Whether or not he gave an A or an F, why he did it matters most. There are people who would give it an "F" and no opinion, and when I accuse them of being cred-hungry jerk oRAB, everyone says their entitled to their opinion.

The thing is, this review says "these are the criteria, and this was how it was met" and by doing this, he doesn't pretend he's cosmic authority on everything.

Far too many people will slag this album to go with the flow. There will be a backlash, but few will say why they went in any direction.
 
Back
Top