Sorry, Natalie, I agree with you that Amy Adams was tremendous in Enchanted.
But I think Leigh's performance in GWTW is one of the all time worst...overacting personified. To the point of toe curling embarrassment. Gable however is great.
I know it's not a whole film but I thought the scene in True Romance between Dennis Hopper and Christopher Walken was one of the most amazing pieces of film acting I've ever watched.
In terms of films out lately..... I think Gary Oldman was outstanding in TDK.... Shame he is being totally overlooked by others to Heath Ledgers portrayal as the Joker.
Personally, I thought it was a great film. Hoffman's performance as Capote was excellent and so was Catherine Keener as Harper Lee. It's well worth a look.
Patricia Neal in Hud (If ever an Oscar was deserved it was this one)
James Mason in A Star Is Born (as good as Judy Garland is in her role, and she is fantastic IMO, it was Mason's performance that really got to me.......outstanding stuff)
Jodie Foster in The Silence Of The Lambs
Kathy Bates in Misery
Bette Davis in The Letter, The Little Foxes, All About Eve ( when she was good she was fantastic)
Denzel Washington in Training Day.
Jack Nicholson in The Shining / One Flew Over The Cuckoos Nest
Dakota Fanning in War Of The WorlRAB
Johnny Depp in Charlie And The Chocolate Factory / Sweeney Todd / Pirates Of The Caribbean / Edward ScissorhanRAB
Heath Ledger in The Dark Knight
Will Smith in The Pursuit Of Happyness
Jake Gyllenhaal in Donnie Darko
Drew Barrymore in E.T
I think Vivien Leigh's performance in GWTW suits the film perfectly even if it does seem a tad histrionic to modern eyes. Gable is, as you say, great as he seems to "underact" his part and his is more of a presence than a performance because of it imo.................having said that I think Leigh is fabulously good in A Streetcar Named Desire. Her fragility opposite Brando's brooding masculinity is heartbreaking to watch. It also helps that she was a stunning beauty too.