Godfather or Goodfellas.

[i love everybody!]

What was the best.

 

[Mee M]

At the moment Godfather.

Although it constantly changes for me.

 

[crazygirl_519]

Oh, Goodfellas...Goodfellas and Casino - godly films.

 

[manadude2]

Goodfellas. At least something happened in that film that was half interesting. I never was as bored as I was watching The Godfather... waiting and waiting for something of any signifcance to happen to make my attention spike, but alas, my eyes just got bored and wandered the longer the film went on. I wish I hadn't bothered buying the trilogy on DVD as the other 2 will not be watched. It was more a case of everyone telling me how good it was and they couldn't believe that I hadn't seen it, so when I finally did, it was more 'meh' than 'marvellous'.

I don't know which one I could pick between Goodfellas and Casino though... both brilliant films.

Paddy

 

[turner25]

I don't think you can compare the two as one is a slow paced trilogy with lots of back story and more in depth look at the characters and how they grew up.

The other is a 2-3 hour film and so everything is more condensed down.

 

[Ebby]

Joe Pesci is the scene-stealer in both the Scorcese films. He really deserved his Oscar for Goodfellas.

Oh, and I would put Goodfellas ahead of Casino, but not by much. Sharon Stone gets on my tits a bit to much.

 

[rivera573344]

The Godfather.

Goodfellas is too trendy for my liking. Everyone in it is cooler than a polar bears arse. Yawn.

 

[travelgirl]

Godfather 2

 

[Eddie[Is Taken]]

Godfather II by a nose, GF's and Casino are both stunning films as well.

Shame to say I don't think Godfather II would work with youngsters today, its a film you have to watch and think about and given the short attention span of many youngsters today it would be doomed to box office failure

 

[~Carrie~ has 5]

Well said that man.

 

[ara]

Such a generalisation if ever there was one. I didn't realise that youngsters were different in your day. Must have been something in the water.

 

[Music-aholic ♪]

I can't decide between them.

I love all of them.....The Godfather (all series of them), Goodfellas (I love Pesci)....and Casino (I thought Sharon, Pesci and De Niro were fantastic)

These films are my all time movies....and I can't fault them at all.

If people think that the Godfather is slow and love Goodfellas, then they have missed the essence of mafia type movies.

The Godfather is the place to start in order to appreciate the others IMHO.

 

[Riin]

The Godather, with ease.

 

[nisar j]

This is a sweeping generalisation but I have to honest and say my 15 year old loved GF 1 but was bored rigid by GF2

 

[ejb_is_me_05]

Most (but not all) youngsters of any generation would struggle with Godfather II, mainly beacuse it's not a film aimed at youngsters.

 

[haytheredollface(:]

I love both movies dearly.

Although i would place Godfather II just ahead of the Godfather. Goodfellas is an excellent movie - one of my all time favourite. Joe Pesci gives one of his greatest ever performance in that movie.

 

[♥Allie misses him♥]

Goodfellas for me, enjoyed both films though.