I just got back from the movie, and I'm surprised to say I loved it! Most of the reviews I read trashed it, and even moviegoers were pretty harsh. After seeing it, I think the hate going around is mostly from fans of the original that were bitter over the remake or expecting a better homage to the 80s version. And that's understandable, but I always felt like the original was slightly overrated anyways, so I wouldn't include myself in that group. I also think people should just look at Fame 2009 as it's own movie, really.
Anyways, back to the film. I agree with others who are complaining about the lack of character development. There were some characters I really enjoyed (Malik, Jenny, Marco, for instance), but even they weren't especially dynamic. However, some of the acting performances were great (especially Collins Pennie and Naturi Naughton), and the teachers really brought a legitimate performing arts pedigree to the movie (Megan Mullally was especially great!) The singing and dancing was better than I thought it would be, because lately I've been sorely underwhelmed by the numbers in dance movies. "Hold Your Dream" was so enjoyable, and I really got into every aspect - the singing, the instruments, the ballet/hip-hop/modern...I mean yeah, it was corny as hell, but what did people expect?
The storylines were a lot different than the original in the way that they weren't very gritty or controversial. But the reasoning behind that I think is that our generation is already pretty well-exposed to topics like sexuality. It was such a poignant thing in the 80s because audiences hadn't seen those types of situations before on screen, necessarily. I definitely wouldn't have minded some touchy subjects being in Fame 2009, because I think movies that challenge audiences are always more respectable and interesting. But I kind of accepted the fact that we wouldn't really be getting much of that in the new movie. Also, I think there was a gay character in the movie named Kevin, but it was never made official. (THIS IS ALL SPECULATION, BY THE WAY) And honestly, I found that kind of refreshing that the movie wasn't forcing the subject by making him the poster child of homosexuality by giving him an, "I'm Gay!" sticker on his head. He was just another character among the rest of the cast, given storylines that outlined issues other than his orientation. Not enough films or TV shows do this with their gay characters.
What I really liked about the 2009 version was the almost reverent portrayal of performing arts. The general messages of the movie are ones we've heard before, yes, but the way they were explored felt (surprisingly) unforced and real. I think that's due to the teachers in the movie, who really nailed their parts and seemed touchingly sincere about what they believe being an artist really means. I think if anyone enjoys dance, theater, singing, etc., then they should appreciate this movie. Don't think because this is a long review, I took the movie really seriously. It was pretty fluffy, but I just wanted to defend it because it's been getting somewhat undeserved bashing. It's not Oscar stuff obviously, but it's fun, and there's definitely talent to be found.