Falkirk v Celtic minutes silence debate?

Kaffo

New member
I feel like Celtic are forcing Falkirk into a no-win situation regarding the minutes silence for Remembrance Sunday. I am ashamed to say that I have never seen an entire Celtic crowd successfully hold a minutes silence. The powers that be know this too and that's why they thought they had won a watch when they came up with this applause thing and called it "the Celtic way". Its not always appropriate and we shouldn't be bowing down to extremists anyway.
Do Celtic have the right to force Falkirk to hold a minute's applause and has anyone actually asked the Celtic support for their opinion?
 
Its shocking if they do change their minds a minutes silence is not to much to ask for.
If its Celtics ground fair enough.
If some celtic fans dont agree,stay away simple.
 
I dont see what the issue is, i think the very fact that a minutes silence or applause is done is a mark of respect. during that minute if Falkirk want to bow there heads and say nothing for a minute then thats theyre choice if Celtic want to clap for a minute thats theirs. I dont see why a big deal has to be made with it, its not like Celtic are the only ones who do this
 
When someone dies i can see why some use the applause to celebrate them but when it comes to Rememberance nothing else bar silence is acceptable.
 
Celtic were the only team in the entire United Kingdom last year to hold a minute's applause, and for Remembrance day, a minute's silence should be the only mark of respect given at a game. It is different to the respect given to an individual who has passed away, where an applause to celebrate their life can be appropriate.

Sadly there was some Republican group last year handing out flyers to ask fans to walk out in protest! Like Kaffo says, Celtic do have a section of their support who refuse to remain silent during these marks of respect.

Im not slating all Celtic fans, just the small minority. Celtic football club should do the minutes silence and any fans who wish to "protest" should have their season tickets ripped up.

Celtic FC's social statement says the club have no political agenda and they should ensure their ground is not used for such political protests - not bow down to the bigots and silence them by doing an applause instead.

My grandad was a Celtic fan of Irish descent and fought in WWII (lying about his age to get into the army at that) - they are insulting thousands of other men just like him who were in a similar position.

Bowing down to a bunch of twisted neds who should bugger off across the Irish sea if they dont like the UK so much is not on - Celtic should do the silence as a mark of respect.

Respecting the Irish roots of the club is one thing, allowing terrorist sympathisers to win over the tens of thousands of Celtic fans who do pay their respects, applause or silence, is another.

Celtic are not a political club, and should not bow down to political opinion of bigots.

Celtic have no right to force any applause on Falkirk and i hope Falkirk do the right thing. If Celtic choose to do an applause at their own ground - i can understand, though not accept why. However, at another ground, its out of their hands.
 
No they do not have a right to force Falkirk to have a minutes worth of applause. It is Falkirks ground and their PA system so it is up to Falkirk to ask for a minutes silence, which I hope they do and I hope it is observed. I do not agree with the applause thing and I do not agree with the two and three minute silences that I have seen creeping in hear and there. You cannot truly reflect on those who have passed and what they have given us during a minutes applause, they should have our undivided attention.
 
Back
Top