Entertainment Weekly's 25 Greatest Animated TV Series

No Avatar: The Last Airbender, don't tell me already M. Night is runing the reputation of the series. Dam him.

I think if they do a list in a year or two, My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic belongs on such a list, but it is too soon.
 
Not a big fan of very many of the shows on the list. I see how they all appeal to some people though. Lots of better shows that should be up there before ATHF, Boondocks, Robot Chicken, and even Adventure Time. (I like it but it's not in the Top 25 ever). I guess we all have different opinions though.
 
No, but longevity is an important aspect of quality. While you may like something now, you simply can't know if it will hold up in the future.

If you're making a list of 'Greatest' things, then obviously you're judging on quality. Recent material has no longevity that can be judged, therefore they shouldn't rank highly for simply not having enough to judge against other competing works on an equal level.
 
I loved Scooby-Doo as a kid and still do, and there were TONS of cartoons on 30 years ago. Scooby-Doo Mystery Incorperated is excellent as well. Say what you will about Scooby, but if it wasn't great, it still wouldn't be airing after 40 years. It got my vote.
 
This list is a lot better than most of these "greatest animated TV series" lists tend to be. For once, it's not just a list of "most well known animated TV series", but rather one where you get the feeling that nearly every single entry is of actual quality, and a lot of them isn't even that well known to the general public. I have to say nearly every single entry though, because of Scooby Doo... :shrug:
 
Like many of the comments on EW's website, I question the exclusion of Daria (especially compared to what was included).

I'm not a huge fan of a lot of these shows. I guess when it comes down to it, the Simpsons would be the best, but I voted for Bebop just because I anticipate it not getting much love with the masses.
 
I vote for king of the hill, thought it was better than family guy, and it and the x files were the only reasons i ever watched fox.
 
Not the best list. Alot of those cartoons I really don't like at all! :p But very glad to see Genndy's "Clone Wars" on there. Which IMO is vastly superior to the newer Clone Wars series.
 
  • Adventure Time - Now this is a surprise, a bit too early to call IMO, I'd sooner give that honor to Regular Show myself but it's also too early to call
  • Animaniacs - Top 25 easily
  • Aqua Teen Hunger Force - Not really top 25 but great
  • Archer - Surprising this showed up but it's not unwarrented
  • Batman: the Animated Series - Of course
  • Beavis and Butt-Head - Typical
  • The Boondocks - Eh... top 25 might be stretching it
  • The Bugs Bunny/Road Runner Show - Adequate Looney Tunes rep
  • Cowboy Bebop - Excellent to see this
  • Family Guy - Expected
  • The Flintstones - Top 25 easily
  • Futurama - Top 25 easily
  • King of the Hill - I could go either way on this
  • Liquid Television - Top 25? I'd say no
  • Ren and Stimpy - Sure
  • Robot Chicken - Not top 25 at all but still good or was anyway
  • Rocky and Bullwinkle - Top 25 easily
  • Rugrats - I guess that's Top 25 worthy
  • Scooby Doo - Yeah that'd be expected in a Top 25
  • The Simpsons - Of course
  • South Park - Expected
  • Spongebob Sqaurepants - Expected
  • Star Wars: Clone Wars (the Genndy Tartakovsky version, not the CGI version) - Go Genndy
  • The Tick - Hmm... I love it but I don't consider it Top 25
  • The Venture Brothers - Excellent to see this
No other DCAU? No Gargoyles? No Marvel (not that's there's much that's Top 25 worthy), No Disney in general? No Avatar: The Last Airbender?

I'd easily strike Robot Chicken, The Tick, The Boondocks and maybe Archer and ATHF for Justice League/JLU, Gargoyles, Avatar: TLA, Spectacular Spider-Man and Darkwing Duck but maybe that's just me. I'd also put One Piece on my Top 25 but well... that's not happening in America. Slightly surprised to not see DBZ but I'm good with Bebop being the only Japanese series on the list.

On the bright side not a single 80s toy commerical to be found though I wouldn't have gripes with The Real Ghostbusters or TMNT showing up among those but as always TMNT 2003 deserves it more than 1987.
 
I think the reason Avatar: TLA didn't make it on here is because the staff at Entertainment just may not care for it that much. I remember reading an article on why The Last Airbender became such a massive disaster in the magazine last year, and one reason listed was that, and Iquote from the magazine, which I have with me

"Sorry, I know it's revered by fans, but the cartoon series is a veritable trash compactor of familiar tropes and effects, borrowing from movies and graphic novels and anime and videogames(sic)."

This may not look that harsh, but "trash compactor" doesn't seem like a very friendly simile to me.

As for some of the choices here, I think The Boondocks deserve a listing. I can't think of an animated sitcom that uses the animation medium to its effect better, aside from maybe Drawn Together, which was a mess in practically every other regard. But for Boondocks, the frame rate is incredible and the designs have vigor to them. They may be "anime-esque", but in motion, the characters have great character. The fight scenes especially look fantastic. Not to mention that it's a genuinely funny show. I wouldn't rank it too high, but there are lesser choices for a list like this.

Archer is a show I'm loving to death now, but I don't know if I'd rank it here yet. I can see what happened with The Venture Brothers, a show I admired for similar reasons in its first two seasons but became too convoluted and raunchy for my liking later on, but for now, I'm in awe. The writing in general is what sells it for me. I love how unapologetically crass the show is, and that it can still handle intelligent the dialogue, how clever the plots, and especially how great the character development can be.

Sterling Archer is an incredibly oafish, chauvinistic lead, but he's so inexplicably likable( perhaps thank H. Jon Benjamin for that? He's really good at making jerks appealing, just by his expressions), and his relationship with his mother is brutal but distressing at the same time. I also dig the sexual tension between both Archer's relationship with Lana Kane, with Sterling and Lana's brief hints of lust and Malory's disapproval of her ability to please her son. The rest of the characters are entertaining as well, with a stellar voice cast, but it's the Archers and Kane that sell that show and make it worthy of making it among the greats, at least at some point.

Adventure Time, though, I'm not so sure I can defend. From what I've seen of the show, it's very creative, has solid characters, and clever designs, but the "awesome sauce" feel that the show pulls off and occasional wonkiness in it's scripts tends to get old. It even seems like the show's diehard fans from early on are losing interest as it goes along. The show's popular now, but will it be considered one of the best in a few years? It seec=ms like other popular Cartoon Network originals from recent years like Foster's, Chowder, and Flapjack are similar in that regard, as well. All are good shows, but I can think of about a half dozen other Cartoon Network originals that deserve to make it here instead of these.

And I'm also not so sure about Aqua Teen, Robot Chicken, or Liquid Television. Well, the latter had a lot of variety and ambition to share, but I'm not so sure if it belongs here. My other big beef comes with Ren & Stimpy, which I think gets more credit and hype than it deserves, but critics seem to love it regardless.

Everything else seems to fit in fine. I'm not a huge fan of Scooby-Doo or SpongeBob SquarePants, but both have left an undeniable impression on the pop culture landscape and on fans that nothing I can say can change. I also wouldn't consider Rugrats for a list like this, at least this high, but the first few seasons are quality, and it broke a couple of records that SpongeBob or any other children's cartoon haven't been able to reach yet.

But the rest seem to fit in fine. Some have undoubtably made a positive impact on the animation landscape, like the Looney Tunes (which got my vote under the incarnation chosen here), The Flintstones, and Batman: TAS, others are welcome and obvious additons, like the Groening shows, Animaniacs, and King of the Hill, and some just have all the reason in the world to appear, like South Park and Family Guy.

I'd like to have seen another anime or two make it on here, but Cowboy Bebop was a dame fine representation on here, and I'm glad that it's an option. In terms of mainstream success and overall quality, it really is the best of both worlds, and nothing else deserves to make it here more.

In hindsight, this is an imperfect selection, but given Entertainment's knack for choosing the most popular, recent options for it's lists, this wasn't so bad. And there are at least one or two shows that could have been ranked but I'm glad didn't make it in, so I at least give it some credit.
 
Back
Top