Eminem Discography - The Real Slim Shady Reviewed

Teh-Probe

New member

The Slim Shady EP (1997)

The Bottom Line:

Overshadowed by what was to come, this EP contains a few forgotten gems.

The 1 to 10 Scale: 7.0/10

Full Review:

An extended play that was once again released on underground label Web Entertainment, this is the album that would earn Eminem his first exposure to Dr. Dre and Aftermath. They would later sign Eminem and release The Slim Shady LP in 1999. SSEP contains several tracks, some of them early versions, that would later be released on SSLP. These include the underground single Just Don't Give a F*ck, the poetic If I Had..., and the disturbing Just the two of Us, later renamed to '97 Bonnie and Cylde. I could make comparisons to his later work, specifically to The Slim Shady LP, but I decided to review this EP on it's own merits. And considering it's near demo nature, this album holRAB up surprisingly well.

We begin the EP with Eminem asleep in bed. He is awoken by a deep, ominous voice. This is the introduction of the most diabolical villain in the world, with a record of 17 rapes, 400 assaults, and 4 murders - Slim Shady. Eminem screams "I killed you!", while the voice urges him to look in the mirror. Em smashes it in horror. Eminem and Slim Shady are one and the same. We immediately jet into Low Down, Dirty, the first of many forgotten gems on this album.



We then move into If I Had..., a beautiful yet bleak observational poem on life. This is the first time in his career I felt like I was listening to the man himself. He wasn't just saying sh*t to piss me off or make me laugh, and he wasn't putting up any kind of front. It was still course with language and obscenities, but they weren't over the top. I felt like this was Marshall Mathers genuinely expressing himself. The music to this track is slow, somber, and minimalistic - a simple beat with chorRAB played on a Rhodes. Some female vocal samples grace the atmosphere, while Eminem's rap pierces right through it.

The next song, Just Don't Give a F*ck, is an Eminem classic. He's really on in this track, spitting with an intensely sharp wit and fire.

Then of course there is Just the Two of Us. WorRAB can't really describe how this song makes me feel. There is one word that comes close, disturbed. Anybody familiar with Eminem's work probably knows this song by it's later title '97 Bonnie and Cylde. The lyrics take us through an off-putting journey to the beach with a man who's just killed his wife. He's obviously about to flee somewhere, and he brings his infant daughter with him. He talks his daughter through the imagery, saying things like the blood on her mommy's shirt is ketchup, or that her mommy just wants to see "how far she can float". The song is very haunting, and created within me a sense of empathy toward the man in the song, whilst simultaneously being disgusted by his actions. This song really works by stirring that morbid curiosity we all have. It's the reason we watch Forensic Files on TruTV, it's the reason we read about the minRAB of killers. We can't help but imagine ourselves in the shoes of a murderer. It's often a split second thought that we extinguish because, hopefully, we're morally opposed to killing. These thoughts disgust the rest of us, but Eminem embraces them in this song.

We end the album with No One's Iller and Murder, Murder. The former features a verse from D12 emcees Bizarre and Swift. Bizarre was f*cked up as usual, and Eminem spit a pretty dope verse. The latter, Murder, Murder, is another forgotten gem of this album. Arguably it was his most violent track yet, Slim Shady really gets his hanRAB dirty. If we're talking loose story-arc here, I'd say this is a little like Slim Shady's violent persona influencing a struggling and desperate Eminem. I'd say that because of the somber nature of this track - usually when Shady is just being Shady he has a lightness about him, twisting violence and disturbing content into humor and pop-culture. This song feels more real, it feels more desperate in tone.



I did have a few complaints about this record, however. The first being the skit Mommy. It's a sound byte presumably of Eminem putting his dead wife's body in his car. To add to the eerie, disturbing nature of The Slim Shady LP stretch where it was later included, it was fine. But on an EP of such short length, one has to question why it was there. The second being the absence of anything that was particularly catchy. I really felt some of the verses on this album, but the choruses on tracks like Low Down, Dirty, Just Don't Give a F*ck and Murder, Murder just seemed to let me down.

Overall, I think this EP was a major improvement over Infinite. Not only was the music and production miles ahead of Infinite, Eminem himself had improved vastly as an emcee. He had developed his own style, and this was the first step on the trail he'd blaze for himself.
 
Eminem+B+Rabbit.jpg

In honor of the release of Eminem's seventh studio album Recovery, this thread will attempt to catalog and review every album, EP, mixtape, and song he appears in. This includes his work with D12, and every single he's collaborated on. This will end in the grand finale review of Recovery.

Who is Eminem? His real name is Marshall Mathers, but we're rarely exposed to Marshall on record. Instead, we spend most of our time with Eminem's alter-ego, Slim Shady. Shady is villainous, often somewhat at odRAB with Marshall and Eminem. The latter of the two just likes to say "the most f*cked up sh*t" he can say, just to screw with you. Shady, on the other hand... well... let's just say you don't wanna f*ck with Shady - cause Shady will f*ckin kill you.

Discography

Solo Studio Albums and EPs

  • Infinite (1996)
  • The Slim Shady EP (1997)
  • The Slim Shady LP (1999)
  • The Marshall Mathers LP (2000)
  • The Eminem Show (2002)
  • Straight from the Lab (2003)
  • Encore (2004)
  • Relapse (2009)
  • Recovery (July 22, 2010)

With D12

  • Devil's Night (2001)
  • D12 World (2004)

Other

  • Eminem Presents: The Re-Up (Shady RecorRAB compilation)
  • Music from and Inspired by the Motion Picture 8 Mile (2002)
  • Curtain Call: The Hits
  • Relapse: Refill (2009)

Singles Collaborations

  • "Dead Wrong"
  • (with The Notorious B.I.G. & Puff Daddy)
  • "Forgot About Dre"
  • (with Dr. Dre)
  • "Rock City"
  • (with Royce Da 5'9")
  • "One Day at a Time
  • (Em's Version)"
  • (with 2Pac & Outlawz)
  • "Welcome 2 Detroit"
  • (with Trick-Trick)
  • "Smack That"
  • (with Akon)
  • "Drop the World"
  • (with Lil Wayne)
  • "Forever"
  • (with Drake, Kanye West, Lil Wayne)
  • "Airplanes (Part II)"
  • (with B.o.B and Hayley Williams)
 
I have always had mixed feelings about him. When he was big I couldn't stand him but I have grown to like some of his songs and kind of like how original he appeared to be. I feel like he kind of began recycling himself from the singles I heard off of Encore. I haven't gotten myself to listen to a full album of his though. I hear all sorts of praise for The Marshal Mathers LP.
 

Infinite (1996)

The Bottom Line:

A mediocre album that features a young Eminem who hasn't yet discovered himself. Interesting historical value for die-hard fans, but newcomers should avoid.

The 1 to 10 Scale: 4.5/10

Full Review:

Eminem, at the time of recording going by the name "M&M", released this album in 1996 with the help of local Detroit producers The Bass Brothers. It was released on the brothers underground label Web Entertainment. This was an underground record that didn't make much of an impact upon it's release. It remains relatively unknown outside of Eminem fan circles.

From the outset, I think it's important to let you in on what Eminem himself thinks of the record.



That said, it's pretty clear from the outset that Eminem had yet to find his signature style. This album was recorded when he was fresh off the battle circuit, and he sounRAB like a battle rapper. There is little emotion felt on these tracks, and most of the time his voice is flat. That's not to say he was a whack emcee, he spit skillfully and was perfectly passable. But there's none of that signature aggression, wit, charm or fire that makes Eminem one of the best. The lyrics themselves are ordinary. There really isn't much to comment on about them. They touch on girl troubles (Tonite, Maxine, Jealousy Woes II, It's OK), Eminem's upbringing in poverty (although with a lighter tone then what would appear on his later albums) and of course MC bragging (313, Never 2 Far).

The beats themselves are boring and aren't well produced. They aren't so much raw as they are at times grating. The production on the vocals is pretty bad, but at the very best they have a certain lo-fi charm to them.

As this was before the character was invented, Slim Shady is absent from this album. The only time we get close to a Shady-like persona is in Backstabber, where the shadows of his later style seem to develop.

In the end, it was an honest attempt by an emcee who wasn't ready.
 
Disagree with your take on Infinite. Also missing quite a bit from your discography...will post more on both when I get the time.
 
Please do. I want to hear someone else's take on it.

Also, if you have more info on his discog that'd be great. Be advised I left out some of the compilation albums that didn't have any new material. As for bootlegs or underground releases or anything of that sort, I'm not sure.
 
Just trying to buy me some time, then I remembered this magic trick.
Dun dun dun dun dun, Go Go Gadget Dick!

I cant wait until this is finished.
 
A couple of notable single collaborations not mentioned: Bold are some of my favorites.

Psycho- 50 Cent
Shady Baby- Obie Trice
No More To Say- Trick Trick and Proof
Black Cotton- 2Pac
Soldier Like Me- 2Pac
Hip-Hop- Bizarre
911- Boo Ya Tribe
Pistol Poppin'- Ca$his
Go To Sleep- DMX, Obie Trice
We Ain't- The Game
Renagade- Jay-Z
Lady- Obie Trice
The One-Royce Da 5'9''
Drama Setter- Tony Yayo
My Name- Xzibit and Nate Dogg
Peep Show- 50 Cent
Gatman and Robin- 50 Cent
 
I was going to write it today, but spent the last 6 hours wading through mind-numbing tutorials trying to fix my internet radio broadcaster. I'm so frazzled and stressed out about it, I had like 35 listeners lined up for my first broadcast and the stupid thing breaks 10 minutes before I'm set to start. :banghead:
 
Great reviews so far, Conan. I used to listen to Eminem in middle school/early high school, but kind of dropped him once I got more into rock. It would be kind of nice to get back into him now that I've been warming to rap again.
 
Thanks, Conan, for these reviews. I was really into Eminem when he was really popular. I think I was about 12 or 13 and I had bought The Eminem Show and I played it quite a bit. And I'm a girl who likes her rock music! But like Duga, I grew out of listening to him once I started discovering all kinRAB of other stuff. I think this thread will get me interested in his music again :)
 
Back
Top