do you think sirius black should have lived?

  • Thread starter Thread starter mrs.sirius black
  • Start date Start date
M

mrs.sirius black

Guest
i do.that monster killing my futur husband!!!! :)
in the books!!!!!!
ok do you think sirius should be daed or not just answer that question.
jk is very ceative she didnt have to kill sirius.dumbledor,very necissary but sirius.she could have come up with something!
you are SOOO right alice.killing peter great.and i suppose she HAD to kill james but remus and sirius so not cool!
 
I think he should of lived, but think about it. It would of made things to easy. Harry needed something to fuel his power to kill Voldemort. If his Dad (well, his godfather) was alive, and he could go live with him at any time, then don't you think the whole story would have changed?
 
Yes he should have lived! Such a waste! He and Harry had so little time together it was heartbreaking.
 
Back
Top