SMITHTOWN, N.Y. -- If you arrived in America with entirely fresh eyes, it would be easy to conclude that the day we celebrate our hard-won independence from England is merely a pause to blow up colorful explosives, grill some meat over an open flame and get good deals on major appliances. And, of course, drink beer.
But that can't be all there is. Can it?
In an era when everything from health care policy to immigration divides us more than it unites us, when the Internet allows us to tear apart our fellow Americans' virtual throats from the comfort of our keyboards, what does a holiday like Independence Day mean?
After 11 score and 16 years, we certainly know how the routine goes.
We gather in our groups, with families and friends and neighbors, and we put politics aside. We cluster in community streets and sit upon community lawns to take in parades, then gaze up at the sky and see the bombs bursting in air and claim, for ourselves, some kind of collective proof that the flag is still there.
But how many of us actually stop and think about our political lot on Independence Day? Cynical though the notion may be, it's hard to find a person who says, "Well, yes, actually, I do engage in discourse about the state of our republic with my fellow Americans between bites of potato salad."
Independence Day can seem like neither a unifier nor a divider. The American heroics discussed are yesterday's, not today's. Everything is torpid and summery and more about the pursuit of happiness than life and liberty. And, in that way, it's about as American as you can get. It's about community in the micro -- about getting together for the fireworks show, not about where our country is these days.
"It's a romantic idealism. We remember what we think America should be," said Tricia Quinn, an architect and a political independent who lives in Orlando.
"On Independence Day, we're trying to put aside our differences and hope that we all believe in the same thing, that we're playing from the same rule book."
Rule book: an interesting term. Think about it for a moment. What do we celebrate today? A declaration of independence -- a conception, really, rather than an actual birth. A decision that we will be a separate nation. But the work -- most of the war to win it, and the compromises necessary to build it -- was still ahead. Independence was asserted in 1776, but the rule book we're playing from, the Constitution, was still 11 years and countless casualties away.
It's the American instinct to celebrate the big, epic, unifying event rather than the tortuous process of give-and-take. Is it possible that we should be celebrating the Constitution rather than the declaration -- the house that Americans actually built rather than merely the idea to build the house?
"The Declaration is about our aspirations, and the Constitution is about how we do it. And how we do it is messy and imperfect," said Brian Mitchell, a historian and past president of Bucknell University. "I think the Declaration is the right thing to celebrate. Because it's about who we want to be."
Much of what puts us at odds is deep-rooted disagreements about precisely who we want to be. More government or less? More immigrants or fewer? More assertiveness in global participation or a drawback?
It's not as if we've always been a very united U.S. We've fought bitterly with each other from the beginning, and of course there was the small matter of a civil war in the 19th Century. But the increasing ability to self-sort -- to create communities both geographic and virtual that effectively wall us off from Americans whose lot and values we don't really share -- wreaks fresh havoc on the ability to get along with the next guy.
Analysis of roll-call votes in Congress tells us that Democrats and Republicans are further apart than at any point in American history, said Mark Oleszek, a political scientist at Albright College in Reading, Pa.
In the end, on Independence Day, the scripted narrative tells us to remember the beginning of something great -- the chance at being exceptional, at growing into the shining city on the hill.
You can question American exceptionalism all you want -- and sometimes, there's a lot to shake your head about -- but in the end, Independence Day is revealed as something quite extraordinary: a holiday that celebrates an idea. Lots came of that idea.
But for the only nation in the world that was built solely upon an idea, to take one day out of the year to celebrate that idea, maybe that isn't such a bad idea in itself -- even if it unfolds amid the exuberant static of multiple Grill-a-Brations and other capitalist outbursts.
But that can't be all there is. Can it?
In an era when everything from health care policy to immigration divides us more than it unites us, when the Internet allows us to tear apart our fellow Americans' virtual throats from the comfort of our keyboards, what does a holiday like Independence Day mean?
After 11 score and 16 years, we certainly know how the routine goes.
We gather in our groups, with families and friends and neighbors, and we put politics aside. We cluster in community streets and sit upon community lawns to take in parades, then gaze up at the sky and see the bombs bursting in air and claim, for ourselves, some kind of collective proof that the flag is still there.
But how many of us actually stop and think about our political lot on Independence Day? Cynical though the notion may be, it's hard to find a person who says, "Well, yes, actually, I do engage in discourse about the state of our republic with my fellow Americans between bites of potato salad."
Independence Day can seem like neither a unifier nor a divider. The American heroics discussed are yesterday's, not today's. Everything is torpid and summery and more about the pursuit of happiness than life and liberty. And, in that way, it's about as American as you can get. It's about community in the micro -- about getting together for the fireworks show, not about where our country is these days.
"It's a romantic idealism. We remember what we think America should be," said Tricia Quinn, an architect and a political independent who lives in Orlando.
"On Independence Day, we're trying to put aside our differences and hope that we all believe in the same thing, that we're playing from the same rule book."
Rule book: an interesting term. Think about it for a moment. What do we celebrate today? A declaration of independence -- a conception, really, rather than an actual birth. A decision that we will be a separate nation. But the work -- most of the war to win it, and the compromises necessary to build it -- was still ahead. Independence was asserted in 1776, but the rule book we're playing from, the Constitution, was still 11 years and countless casualties away.
It's the American instinct to celebrate the big, epic, unifying event rather than the tortuous process of give-and-take. Is it possible that we should be celebrating the Constitution rather than the declaration -- the house that Americans actually built rather than merely the idea to build the house?
"The Declaration is about our aspirations, and the Constitution is about how we do it. And how we do it is messy and imperfect," said Brian Mitchell, a historian and past president of Bucknell University. "I think the Declaration is the right thing to celebrate. Because it's about who we want to be."
Much of what puts us at odds is deep-rooted disagreements about precisely who we want to be. More government or less? More immigrants or fewer? More assertiveness in global participation or a drawback?
It's not as if we've always been a very united U.S. We've fought bitterly with each other from the beginning, and of course there was the small matter of a civil war in the 19th Century. But the increasing ability to self-sort -- to create communities both geographic and virtual that effectively wall us off from Americans whose lot and values we don't really share -- wreaks fresh havoc on the ability to get along with the next guy.
Analysis of roll-call votes in Congress tells us that Democrats and Republicans are further apart than at any point in American history, said Mark Oleszek, a political scientist at Albright College in Reading, Pa.
In the end, on Independence Day, the scripted narrative tells us to remember the beginning of something great -- the chance at being exceptional, at growing into the shining city on the hill.
You can question American exceptionalism all you want -- and sometimes, there's a lot to shake your head about -- but in the end, Independence Day is revealed as something quite extraordinary: a holiday that celebrates an idea. Lots came of that idea.
But for the only nation in the world that was built solely upon an idea, to take one day out of the year to celebrate that idea, maybe that isn't such a bad idea in itself -- even if it unfolds amid the exuberant static of multiple Grill-a-Brations and other capitalist outbursts.