Code Geass live action movie? Yay or nay?

Suck? You've sold me on the idea, right there! I was about to say "Hell no!" and question the need to bump this thread! Time to start on the screenplay. This is going to be so bad it's good.

It all makes sense when you remeraber that Japan is big on discontinuous re-imaginings of popular franchises. If we're going to create botched live-action films from anime, we might as well do it right.

--Romey
 
It certainly had "issues" as you put it. But I don't need a perfectly and logically executed story to enjoy a series. What I do need are likable characters, and for me CG was completely devoid of them. I seriously couldn't stand any of them. This is why I am all for a live action CG, that way(depending on casting and a story rewrite) maybe I will finally get someone to root for.
 
I see. That position certainly makes enough sense for you, but not for me...because I honestly didn't have that reaction. Regardless of not always agreeing with their actions, which is one thing, I still liked several merabers of the cast. Then again, this really happens to be one of those discussions that could potentially go on and on as long as conflicting opinions continue to be strongly held.

In other worRAB, we will ultimately have to agree to disagree.

More to the point, I've also never liked the live-action equivalent of an anime/cartoon character more than the original.
 
Yeah, you have a point there. It's much easier to adapt fanservice and over-the-top giant robot fights than complex characters and plots. It would all depend on the company that produces it and the director and writer and such.
 
Which is why I qualified my previous posts in this thread with "for me" and "in my opinion". I guess that's why it would make sense to me seeing as how it is my opinion.

I agree with agreeing to disagree as that should have been an inevitable conclusion drawn from reading my very first post. But I disagree that this discussion could potentially go on and on. You like the show and don't want to see it live action, I dislike the show which is why I would be curious to see if I would enjoy a different version. At this point we have exhausted this discussion as it falls upon personal preference, and there is no debating person preference.

On a personal note, I thank you for such polite responses, there is no reason for people with differing opinions to get "snarky" with each other.
 
Back
Top