Can we Muslims really argue with Koranist when they don't have any knowledge of...

I

Immortal Verses 2.0

New member
...the Quran? "I debated a scholar and beat him. Then I debated a layman and that layman beat me - he had no knowledge of the principles and texts. I had nothing to say."
- Imam Ash-Shafi'i
مَّنْ يُطِعِ الرَّسُولَ فَقَدْ أَطَاعَ اللّهَ ÙˆÙŽÙ…ÙŽÙ† تَوَلَّى فَمَا أَرْسَلْنَاكَ عَلَيْهِمْ Ø*َفِيظًا
He who obeys the Messenger, obeys Allah. but if any turn away, we have not sent Thee to watch over their
Plus what am I suppose to do when they just block me? :'(
Sonja,
You prove without of a shadow of a doubt that Koranist have no intelligence. I have no respect for anyone who rejects the Qur'an. Sorry but I have no respect for Koranist.

"and we made the Qiblah which You used to face, Only to test those who followed the Messenger from those who would turn on their heel"
Ninety9,
Exactly. You could not have put it better. Its the deen of nafs or Shaitan.
Dodo,
I have sent you a message. But there has not been on sahih ahadith that has been found that has contradicted the Qur'an.
 
Im a sunni muslim but recently Ive been questioning a lot of things about Islam. I found this koranist website and honestly it made more sense. Soo many things in the hadith don't make sense and contradict what the Quran has said. How can a religion of perfection, the religion of the true god have contradictions? I don't want to be ignorant and not think about these contradictions like the christians do with the trinity. I think its because the hadith were either lost in translation, not accurate, or meddled with.

Every word in the Quran is to perfection, its the hadith that wont enter my brain.

EDIT: you are right lebanese spirit. I agree.
It's so lame how I got thumbs down but nobody has debated me. Ignorance is the most dangerous thing I swear. We are all here to learn new things and to debate.
 
Yes in sha'aa llah we can.... u leave them, they will think that they are right.... u fight them with Knowledge and u beat them bcz they cant give u what beats u.

do u get what i mean?

make a new account and hunt them down :)

@ Dodo:
hmmm i read a lot about ppl being lost bcz of some websites.
be careful u dont fall in an anti islamic website....

ppl u should be strong !

nways Yes quran is perfect... hadith arent... not every hadith is authentic, some are weak... some have a broken chain etc... and im sure the website u read in... gave u the weak ahadith.

u cant leave ahadith bcz then u wont be able to pray or to make hajj.... since prayers have rak'aats etc... and since hajj is about Tawaaf or walking around the Ka’bah seven times, al-Saa’ee or running between the hills of Safaa’ and Marwa seven times, standing at ‘Arafaah, stoning the Jamaraat (stone pillars representing the Shaytaan) at Mina,etc


and all this isnt mentioned in quran.... so to make it short take the ahadith which doesnt contradicts with quran....thats it.

@ Dodo:

take care sis =) assalamo alaykom =)
 
u gotta admit though, Koranism (which is a slander to the Quran to call their sect that) is the easiest sect to be in, u are ur own scholar and u issue ur own fatwas, and make up ur own rules and laws, and reject whatever u dont like, and accept whatever u like that best fits ur lifestyle

they got nothing to lose
 
Back
Top