First, look up reviews online for each car. That will give you an idea of what the experts said about them when they came out, and what other drivers thought about them, who owned them.
Next, look up their value on kelly blue book (kbb.com) and edmunds.com. That will give you an idea of what either of those should be selling for, based on their condition. Then you can decide if they are priced "right" for you.
I don't make many purchases these days without looking up reviews and doing some price comparisons online...that way you can feel better about getting a good value when you do choose to spend your money.