Black Dahlia/Scanner Darkly

[MissPiggy]

im thinking of buying these but was wondering which one was better as everywhere i go they are

 

[desperate]

A Scanner Darkly is way better. The Black Dahlia is rubbbish

 

[ShrinkyDink]

Definitely agree about The Black Dahlia: shambolic.

 

[Persephone]

Scanner Darkly DEFINITELY, and I haven't even seen it - but it's supposed to be very faithful to the book, which is brilliant.
Black Dahlia was awful. A bit like a self-indulgent and very confused version of LA Confidential (which was a great film by the way).