Beast Wars vs. Beast Machines

H

Hud

New member
Beast Wars and Beast Machines are both in the same canon, but radically different shows. Which show did you think was better?
 
Beast Wars easily,

My biggest gripe with BM was the whole Cybertron becomes a giant garden,FOR GOD'S SAKES,IT'S A HOMEWORLD FOR ROBOTS!!!!!!!

thank you.
 
I loved Beast Wars, they had many good episodes and plots. That show was just great, especially one to grow up with (one of the many gret shows of the 90's).
 
Beast Wars was an excellent show that had real character development given to its main cast. Plus, this was at a time when Mainframe Entertainment was in its prime, having excellent CG animation and top notch writing.

Beast Machines on the other hand, just was overrun with bad writing altogether and even dumber plots. I'm sure everyone wanted the guy who came up with the whole "organic cybertron" idea to burn at the stake.
 
My opinion was definitly Beast Wars. Beast Wars had a great plot and wonderful characters.

Beast Machines just messed up everything that was established in Beast Wars like Rhinox being evil and all this stupid organic junk.
 
Beast Wars was the better series, but I think there was some great potential in Beast Machines.

Beast Machine Spoilers
Like how Optimus Primal went completely insane, and I liked how Rhinox was first forced to be evil then decided he wanted to stay that way.

There were a lot of curveballs thrown in the series, but I think because of the length of the series they came too quickly and felt forced.
 
Pretty much every character underwent a useless paradigm shift. Heck, just look at what they did to Rattrap.

And the dialogue... gah. I thought the early episodes of Beast Wars had terrible dialogue, but they have nothing on some of the stuff in Beast Machines.
 
While the general idea for Beast Machines was pretty flawed to begin with, I thought there were some good spots. There were indeed a lot of pointless character and philosophy changes, but I could appreciate it as a standalone series. Finding out the fate of the various Beast Wars characters and the cause for Megatron's rule over Cyberton is what kept me watching. There was just too many bad things in Beast Machines to even compare it to Beast Wars. I got to talk to Scott McNeil at one of the anime conventions last year, and even he vocalized his disdain for Beast Machines.

As for Beast Wars, I think that's been pretty much covered.
 
Wow, someone voted for BM? That's a surprise.

Anyway, Beast Wars was essentially a better show. A better story, better characters, and overall better atmosphere.
 
Back
Top