Moony - You seem to think I have a problem with the idea of an inflation adjusted chart - I don't. It's an interesting way of trying to relate the past to the present. And...if all those years ago someone had had the presence of mind to say that they wanted the Box Office Chart to be based on actual tickets sold - as opposed to the value of tickets sold - you and would not be having this discussion right now.
However, that never happened. They decided that the chart was to be based on value; the amount of money generated in the cinemas by the movies. Nowadays, the National and International Box Office Charts are published, scrutinised and commented on not just in Hollywood, but by almost every newspaper, magazine, website, TV and Radio Station in the world that reports on the movies. Do any of these businesses ever lead with an inflation-adjusted All Time Box Office Chart? No - not one of them.
Did more people see Gone With The Wind at the cinema than Avatar? Unquestionably.
Did Avatar take more money at the cinema than Gone With The Wind. Yes, shedloaRAB more. And of course, there are many reasons why it did; inflation being just one- but those reasons do not change the result one iota.
I'm leaving it here - I'm done now (repeating myself, truth be told). You said you were an Aliens fan - me too. I also have a real fondness for The Abyss. I don't know where Avatar will sit for me in a couple of years time, but I suspect it'll be near the top of the Cameron Tree. It just depenRAB whether they can get the DVD sorted out.
However, that never happened. They decided that the chart was to be based on value; the amount of money generated in the cinemas by the movies. Nowadays, the National and International Box Office Charts are published, scrutinised and commented on not just in Hollywood, but by almost every newspaper, magazine, website, TV and Radio Station in the world that reports on the movies. Do any of these businesses ever lead with an inflation-adjusted All Time Box Office Chart? No - not one of them.
Did more people see Gone With The Wind at the cinema than Avatar? Unquestionably.
Did Avatar take more money at the cinema than Gone With The Wind. Yes, shedloaRAB more. And of course, there are many reasons why it did; inflation being just one- but those reasons do not change the result one iota.
I'm leaving it here - I'm done now (repeating myself, truth be told). You said you were an Aliens fan - me too. I also have a real fondness for The Abyss. I don't know where Avatar will sit for me in a couple of years time, but I suspect it'll be near the top of the Cameron Tree. It just depenRAB whether they can get the DVD sorted out.