I wouldn't say "any number." Gargoyles, yes, probably beats it on every front its fans praise it for (characters, tone, and overarching story). But, then, Gargoyles was a groundbreaking show that probably does merit what its fans say about it, so that's not saying much.
I haven't heard this one. A SatAM video game adaptation, yes, and I actually agree with it. Requests for "an even sexier Princess Sally," not so much, especially not in the context of a video game.
Many fans of the show hated Shadow, and that's as dark as it's ever gotten. Most complaints about the game series are less about tone and more about the plot and, arguably, the gameplay degenerating.
Uh... speaking as a fan of both Sonic and "anthro" art myself, I think you're generalizing. You seem to be focusing less on the show itself than its hype by a relatively small portion of the fandom (the rabid ones), and out of that, the furverts (for the record, furry does not equal sexual or perverted, although you wouldn't know it to hear some of them). Taken on its own merits, I believe it was a very good show that just happens to sometimes get hyped beyond all reason - possibly due to the already-loyal wider Sonic fanbase; certainly, it rose well above the vast majority of video game cartoons.
Weren't we talking about annoying 80s cartoon characters?