Anime Categories for Western Cartoons

Shounen is for young boys while Seinen is for adult males, so yes those would be accurate. Shoujo is for young girls and Josei is for adult women.. though America doesn't really have any cartoons for girls anymore. Kodomo is anime for small children, so it would be the equivalent of Nick Jr. and the like, I suppose.
 
Avatar = Shounen
King of the Hill = Seinen
Adventure Time = Shounen
Generator Rex = Shounen
Totally Spies = possibly Shoujo
Strawberry Shortcake = Shoujo
Spongebob = not exactly gender-specific so I'm not sure
Adult Swim originals = Seinen
The Simpsons and Seth Macfarlane shows = slice-of-life
Futurama = Seinen probably
 
You're not alone. I mean, there's more anime genres than the usual Shojo, Shonen, Josei, etc. stuff.

And personally, Futurama doesn't really have one genre. It's more at home with whatever Baccano! and Durarara!! are supposed to be.
 
Shounen, seinen, and the like are all demographics based on who the particular show is aimed at. However, it doesn't indicate that boys won't watch a "girly" show and vice versa. Black Butler runs in a shounen magazine, and it definitely has a strong female fanbase. Labeling something as "shounen" just means it's aimed at boys. In my opinion, it works better with manga magazines, just because it more or less says "-insert genre/plot/etc.- will not be in -this magazine- in any large quantity. An angst-filled romance will not be in Shonen Jump. The only series that seem to be able to pop up everywhere are ones like Chi's Sweet Home, which carries universal appeal and runs in a seinen magazine.

That said, I find it much more difficult to find a particular demographic for most American animation in Japanese terms. Shows on CN or Nickelodeon have an appeal to both males and females, even if lacking female characters. The Simpsons, Futurama, South Park, and others are comedies targeted at anyone who enjoys them. It's not about a serious adventure and none have several raunchy scenes depicted seriously and/or meant to appeal particularly to men or women. A lot of it is day-to-day activities, politics, or satire/parodies of life.

With the exception of children shows, adult animation is very broad in appeal, partly because it has to be, I'd imagine. Not as many adults will be watching cartoons compared to children. You'll always have a bunch of girls willing to watch Strawberry Shortcake or Holly Hobbie, and the rest of the "male" shows end up attracting a fair share of females (it's also not explicit that it's aimed at males in the first place, while most anime is fairly easy to label). There a few exceptions, I suppose--Avatar could likely be called shounen.
 
That's not what the word means. Naruto has female appeal as well, but it's still for boys. Nick and CN's shows are clearly for one gender or the other (usually boys, since executives here don't think girls watch cartoons)
 
I know that. As I said, it's a demographic (that was a simply misuse of wording that the rest of my post should have made up for). However, many shows on CN and Nickelodeon are aimed at both. They may fear using a female cast because they don't want to alienate their male audience, but the primary mindset is to make a show that both will watch and enjoy. Males are far more reluctant to admit to watching a "girly" show or will admittedly avoid shows they deem as such.

I'd be more willing to label most as just general kodomo. It's more than likely that the studio heads want a series that can be easily aimed at both. Getting everyone to watch The Wild Thornberries is much less a task than promoting Strawberry Shortcake as a show for males too.

Applying Japanese terms to American (and probably most Western nations') cartoons becomes murky because of the general nature of the market. The studio's aims are different and the shows produced are different.
 
I don't know. If those categories are off base, then logically we ought to refrain from calling anything a "kid's show" as well. But I don't think that's necessary. One can recognize something for what it is and also believe that a broader audience can and/or should enjoy it.
 
Nope. The model is grossly outdated, and studio execs need to pull their heads out of the sand and start looking at the TOTAL ratings, not just the numbers the "target demographic" pulls in. They do this for age too. If a cartoon they assumed would be popular with kids draws in a core fanbase of college students they'll cancel it and declare it a dud. :/

The biggest difference between the way the US classifies demographics, and the way Japan does, is that no one bats an eye in Japan if a girl watches shounen or seinin, nor is there a big stink if a boy watches shojou or josei (maybe a little teasing from the other boys, but josei can get pretty brutal so it's not all that different from seinin...). In fact, they're well aware of the large female fanbase many shounen shows have. They merchandise to it. I mean, really, when you look at some of the stuff you can get for Bleach or Gintama, do you REALLY think they had boys in mind for these products? XD
 
Actually, if you look at the data the networks care about, just about the only demographic they care about is boys.

http://www.rabroad.net/_news/articles/34421/cable-tv-ratings-family-guy-greater-than-spongebob

These reports only care about boys usually, since the sad fact is most executives don't think girls watch cartoons or are a viable market.

I wouldn't say that; shounen isn't all action. There's various romance titles, like Strawberry 100%, Midori Days, and harem shows in general; comedy titles; and tons of different genres. The only thing that makes it shounen is that it's aimed at boys. The reverse is also true; shoujo isn't all romance, there's action shows like PreCure and Cutey Honey.
 
Those were just examples. I just don't find it correct to brand something based on its presumed audience, especially when they specify immutable traits. Can you imagine the outrage if Japanese distributors called The Simpsons a "gaijin" show, or The Boondocks a "kurojin" cartoon?
 
You know, I've always wondered. Does Japan even use these terms for actual categorizing, such as movie advertising or DVD covers? Or is it just an "otaku" thing? I imagine that if I go to the Japanese equivalent of Blockbuster, they'll have things organized by Drama, Comedy, Action, Romance, and stuff like that.
 
I've been in websites like DiGiket where they have separate sections for works aimed at males and females. You can imagine what kind of stuff they have at the "Men's" section. Curiously, most of the "Women's" section is yaoi or shota (apparently they don't believe there's such a thing as gay men).
 
BL isn't targeted at men. Those series are made for (and usually by) women and characters and stories are crafted in such a way to appeal to them. Not to say men don't read it, but the fanbase is largely women and girls. Males looking for series about gay men are likely to go with bara.
 
I always thought it was because our society is more accepting of girls liking "boy stuff" then they are about boys liking "girl stuff". So they think if something is aimed at girls only girls will watch it, but if it's aimed at boys, boys AND girls will watch it.
 
Back
Top