Although i didnt read all of the posts, i will share my experience with Amsoil.
This past winter, I did my ape hanger install on my '06 RK and since i was due for an oil change... I decide to give Amsoil a try....plus a buddy was a dealer and I got it for about $8 something a qt and i used their filter. After about 2000 miles I had to add a qt to bring it back to level....and at the 6000 mile mark (this is when I change oil, no need to interject!) it would've had to have another qt to bring back to level.
I have since switched back to SYN3...and to be honest...the engine sounds quieter....tighter and is not drinking oil....
so, for my experience.....I will stick with SYN3
plus.....as my good buddy has told me....there are HD dealers all over the country...SYN3 is easy to find if you need to do an oil change on a road trip.....Amsoil may require some searching!