A Christmas Carol

[Allie hunter]

Scrooge. Which is your favorite version? Mine would be the Alistair Sim one with the Patrick Stewart one next.

Out of all its incarnations, muppets, musicals, comedies etc, which one do you like best

I'm surprised they haven't made a zombie version yet lol

 

[Dr.Tran]

Yep, the Alistair Sims one. Then the Blackadder one!

 

[cathy h]

Muppets for me. Although the George C Scott TV moive is good too.

 

[abdoodls]

Definitely Alistair Sim although I didn't really like the colourised version of the movie.

 

[wildhorse i]

Scrooged with Bill Murray was my fave! Still get excited every time it's on TV at Christmas. So Sad!

 

[Terisa]

I was looking forward to the new version, until I found out Jim Carrey was in it.

 

[boatwoman]

I really like the Albert Finney musical.

There was also an animated version that was on TV back in the 1970s. Absolutely terrified me as a kid. Trying to find some stills from it.

 

[Maverick Michelle]

Muppets christmas carol was always my favorite.

 

[NKO the new legend killer]

The animated version by Richard Williams.

Excellent and very atmospheric.

A quick search on Google video and here it is:

http://video.google.com/videosearch...ard+williams&emb=0&aq=3&oq=christmas+carol+r#

Looks like it's taken from a VHS copy and isn't great quality, but it's watchable.

 

[bunkerfan]

Definitely Muppets, then the Hallmark adaptation with Patrick Stewart.

Damn me for not being old school.

 

[Tom T09]

Love all Ebenezer's takes though probably my least favorite was the musical version with Albert Finney.

Although cheap and made for tv I love Patrick stewarts version

 

[Razieh A]

Anyone see the Mickey Mouse one? I loved that as a child, my little one likes it aswell

 

[courtneyrhodeisland]

My fvourite version is the Alistair Sim version.
The new Jim Carrey one looks a load of tripe to me.

 

[!*Lil Me*!]

He only provides voices for Scrooge and the 3 ghosts, he's not in it as such - although, they have based the look of some of the characters on the people who provide the voices. Very similar to the look of the Polar Express.

 

[John Bradley]

That, too, is my favourite! Really makes me feel Christmassy!

 

[Jeria]

I agree, Mickeys Christmas Carol is a really nice version

 

[toocladashis]

The Muppets version and the Mickey Mouse version are my favourites. I love them so much I don't really care for any other adaptaion I've seen. Michael Caine is the ultimate Scrooge to me.

 

[Chelsea R]

I like the musical version. There's an older version I really like.. can't remember how old though.

 

[KobeBryantMVP]

what is the one with the kate winslet song in it.

 

[Mazen H]

Watched the 3D one this afternoon.

Really was a load of rubbish! the 3D just didn't work in this film. Not sure if this sounRAB right, but for 3D to work you need things to come flying out at you on the screen. Sadly the only thing leaping out of the screen was a pile of shyte!

If you must go and see this I wouldn't waste money on the 3D version, go and see it in 2D