PeterLucas wrote:
I think most experts would disagree. That's a very rapid rate
of weight loss, and four months is far too short of an interval to be
claiming any sort of success. It could well be the beginning of
(or the continuance of, depending on history) a cycle of yo-yo
dieting.
I would be more inclined to say he's doing bloody well if the
weight loss were more moderate. (Depending on scenario; there are
situations, such as the need to lose weight for a medically
necessary surgical procedure, when you do really need to lose
weight that rapidly.)
However I do wish kili's buddy luck, and hope he meets his personal
goals on a sustained basis.
Steve