I had a VTX 1300, an 1800, and an 06 Ultra at the same time! The Harley had a more refined fit and feel than either of the two VTX's and rode a little smoother than the Hondas, but either of the Hondas would run circles around the Ultra and both had smoother transmissions. The shaft drives on the Hondas were head and shoulders above the belt drive used on the Harley, and you didn't have to disassemble half the bike to replace it. Water cooling was a definate plus. Harley wins the fuel mileage race hands down! The ultra (an 88 CI) consistantly ran 48-50 MPG, the VTX 1300 did 42-45 and the VTX1800 ran 34-37 MPG. BTW: the Harley pulled 63HP AT THE WHEEL, the 1300 pulled 66, and the 1800 pulled an even 100 HP. All the dyno pulls were done the same day. Harleys ARE CHEAPER to accessorize, rebuild, and since there's no valves to adjust, service CAN be cheaper! Harley has MUCH better brakes! So why did I go Harley? It's the DEALER NETWORK, parts availability, better fit and finish and Harley being every bit as reliable as the Hondas! My dealer worked VERY hard to earn my business and still works hard to keep me happy! Not so with Honda, and I used to work there! I'm on my 4th new Ultra since 2006, and as soon as Harley builds a water cooled Ultra, I'll have one.