I heard that Murphy wasn't set to perform in the first place...he wasn't on the list of performers...:shrug:
Ever since the airing of nominations for "Short Live Action Films," I've been really antsy. I NEED to see West Bank Story. If anyone knows of where to find it online...please tell. It's driving me nuts. It looks so incredibly cool.
Re: Hudson winning.. I was glad she did. While this IS a show that acknowledges fantastic performances in acting, acting doesn't have to be cut down to ONLY the delivery of monologues. Acting is about believingly conveying a character on screen, and filling the character with energy, (believability), and emotion. Though most of J.Hud's work wasn't delivering monologues of lines that show how well she can talk-act, her performance, IMO, was everything that a win (or nomination) for an Oscar is:
She showed passion, incredibly strong emotions, of various kinds, throughout that film. Some songs showed her character's attitude and strength, while others showed her desperation and vulnerability, and others showed her character's desire for a second chance, for forgiveness.
I was in awe of her performace in Dreamgirls. It is not everyday that you see a person who can fill a character on-screen with such power that she did. She has real presence. I don't expect her to pursue acting as a career, as I have no idea if she has much acting talent in delivering lines of dialogue while showing off a character. It was almost luck that the character of Effie was exactly the kind of character that J. Hudson would fill perfectly--the role of a singer (not just because she sings, also because you can believe that she's a singer by how she acts when she's NOT singing. I don't know if she could play a non-singer character as well.
She deserved the Oscar IMO. But I have a feeling, that while this is the beginning of her career, the hype is going to wear off eventually. She deserved her 15+ minutes of fame. Now she'll go off, make a record, get some sales, etc...like any other singer in the industry. And other unknowns will get their spotlight.