Thinker Man Made Paradise
New member
Mine:
Best: (Ritchie Benaud would top all polls but he rarely commentate now)
1)Geoffrey Boycott (Technically the best, honest and decisive)
2)Nasser Hussain (Great insight and knowledge)
3)Ravi Shastri (Totally unbiased and very pragmatic)
4)Sanjay Manjrekar (groomed for commentating)
5)Henry Blofeld (legendary voice and enthusiasm)
6)Jeremy Coney (Provides very good observations)
7)Simon Hughes (The Analyst revolutionised some of the modern concepts in commentating)
8)Michael Holding (fast bowlers input and underrated)
9)Robin Jackman (clear and consistent)
10)Pommie Mbangwa (matured and developed)
Least favourite:
1)Harsha Bhogle (Absolutely no clue about the game)
2)Ian Chappell (Totally lost it should retire, he used to be ok)
3)Ramiz Raja (embroils the game and even his contradicts at times)
4)Arun Lal (slow and non-articulate)
5)Bob Willis (50/50 never sure which Bob turns up)
6)Nick Knight (frenetic should be removed from International games)
7)David Lloyd (comical but very irrational)
Questionable:
1)Tony Grieg (Should retire, keep off the screen and commentating)
2)David Gower (Adds no value and is an eye sore on presentation)
3)Mark Nicholas (indefinable role)
Best: (Ritchie Benaud would top all polls but he rarely commentate now)
1)Geoffrey Boycott (Technically the best, honest and decisive)
2)Nasser Hussain (Great insight and knowledge)
3)Ravi Shastri (Totally unbiased and very pragmatic)
4)Sanjay Manjrekar (groomed for commentating)
5)Henry Blofeld (legendary voice and enthusiasm)
6)Jeremy Coney (Provides very good observations)
7)Simon Hughes (The Analyst revolutionised some of the modern concepts in commentating)
8)Michael Holding (fast bowlers input and underrated)
9)Robin Jackman (clear and consistent)
10)Pommie Mbangwa (matured and developed)
Least favourite:
1)Harsha Bhogle (Absolutely no clue about the game)
2)Ian Chappell (Totally lost it should retire, he used to be ok)
3)Ramiz Raja (embroils the game and even his contradicts at times)
4)Arun Lal (slow and non-articulate)
5)Bob Willis (50/50 never sure which Bob turns up)
6)Nick Knight (frenetic should be removed from International games)
7)David Lloyd (comical but very irrational)
Questionable:
1)Tony Grieg (Should retire, keep off the screen and commentating)
2)David Gower (Adds no value and is an eye sore on presentation)
3)Mark Nicholas (indefinable role)