Witnesses recall women's horror during Ariel Castro sentencing - CNN

Diablo

New member
  • Ariel Castro's sister says he must pay for what he did
  • Castro will deliver a statement explaining his life, the sister says
  • He'll be sentenced Thursday; the plea deal calls for life plus at least 1,000 years
  • One victim, Michelle Knight, will likely speak at hearing


(CNN) -- The Ohio man who imprisoned three women in his Cleveland home for a decade will speak at length during his sentencing Thursday, delivering a statement that his sister promises will allow people to see "the other side of Ariel Castro."
Castro pleaded guilty last week to 937 counts, including murder and kidnapping, in a deal that dropped a possible death penalty in exchange for life in prison plus 1,000 years.
He'll give a rather lengthy statement, explaining his life and who he really is, his sister, Marisol Alicea, told CNN on Wednesday night.
"(People will) see the other side of Ariel Castro ... not the monster that everyone thinks he is," she said, adding that she was in no way defending her brother.
"He must pay for what he did."
bttn_close.gif

130709063813-amanda-berry-0709-horizontal-gallery.png
Amanda Berry speaks in a video released on YouTube on Monday, July 8, thanking people for support and privacy. Berry, Gina DeJesus and Michelle Knight escaped from a Cleveland home on May 6 after being held captive for nearly a decade.

130506221059-amanda-berry-horizontal-gallery.png
Amanda Berry vanished a few blocks from her Cleveland home on April 21, 2003. She was 16.

130709064022-gina-dejesus-0709-horizontal-gallery.png
Gina DeJesus speaks in the YouTube video.

130506221101-georgina-gina-dejesus-horizontal-gallery.png
Georgina "Gina" DeJesus was last seen in Cleveland on April 2, 2004, on her way home from school. She was 14 when she went missing.

130709063857-michelle-knight-0709-horizontal-gallery.png
Michelle Knight speaks in the YouTube video.

130508084006-michelle-knight-horizontal-gallery.jpeg
Knight was last seen on August 22, 2002, when she was 21.

130801072640-knight-letter-police-horizontal-gallery.jpg
In a handwritten note, Knight thanked Cleveland police for their efforts, saying she was overwhelmed with the support she had received from "complete strangers." The note was posted Wednesday, July 31, on the police's Second District Community Relations Committee Facebook page.

130509212846-01-ohio-kidnapped-0509-horizontal-gallery.jpg
Residents gather outside a community meeting at Immanuel Lutheran Church on Thursday, May 9, to talk about the kidnapping case in Cleveland. Balloons were released as part of the ceremony.

130509213219-02-ohio-kidnapped-0509-horizontal-gallery.jpg
FBI agents and other law enforcement officers stand outside suspect Ariel Castro's home in Cleveland on May 9. Castro, a former school bus driver, has been accused of holding three women captive for a decade in his house. He has also been charged with rape.

130509213652-03-ohio-kidnapped-0509-horizontal-gallery.jpg
Castro hangs his head low while talking with his public defender, Kathleen DeMetz, during his arraignment on May 9.

130509213905-04-ohio-kidnapped-0509-horizontal-gallery.jpg
Ada Colon prays during a vigil held in honor of the kidnapping victims in Cleveland on Wednesday, May 8.

130508231744-01-ohio-kidnapped-0508-horizontal-gallery.jpg
Relatives of kidnapping victim Georgina "Gina" DeJesus hug after she returned to her parents' home in Cleveland on May 8.

130508232407-02-ohio-kidnapped-0508-horizontal-gallery.jpg
Friends and neighbors cheer as a car carrying Amanda Berry arrives at her sister's house in Cleveland on May 8.

130508232523-03-ohio-kidnapped-0508-horizontal-gallery.jpg
Gina DeJesus gives a thumbs up as she arrives at her family's house in Cleveland on May 8.

130509155235-ariel-castro-mugshot-0508-horizontal-gallery.jpg
Ariel Castro was charged on May 8 with kidnapping the three women.

130507204138-10-ohio-kidnapped-0507-horizontal-gallery.jpg
The family house of Gina DeJesus has been decorated by well-wishers on Tuesday, May 7.

130507204141-11-ohio-kidnapped-0507-horizontal-gallery.jpg
Friends and relatives gather in front of the family house of DeJesus on May 7.

130507204144-12-ohio-kidnapped-0507-horizontal-gallery.jpg
Well-wishers visit the home of the sister of Amanda Berry on Monday, May 6.

130507204147-13-ohio-kidnapped-0507-horizontal-gallery.jpg
Investigators remove evidence from the house on Seymour Avenue in Cleveland where the three women were held.

130507204149-14-ohio-kidnapped-0507-horizontal-gallery.jpg
An FBI forensics team meets outside the house where three women were held as they investigate the property.

130507204152-15-ohio-kidnapped-0507-horizontal-gallery.jpg
An FBI forensics team member removes evidence from the house.

130507172138-04-ohio-kidnapped-0507-horizontal-gallery.jpg
A relative of DeJesus brings balloons to the home of Amanda Berry's sister in Cleveland on May 7.

130507172140-05-ohio-kidnapped-0507-horizontal-gallery.jpg
Children hold a sign and balloons in the yard of Gina DeJesus' family home in Cleveland on May 7.

130507172142-06-ohio-kidnapped-0507-horizontal-gallery.jpg
Bystanders and media gather on May 7 along Seymour Avenue in Cleveland near the house where the three women were held captive.

130507172145-07-ohio-kidnapped-0507-horizontal-gallery.jpg
A bystander shows the front page of The Plain Dealer newspaper to a friend outside of the house on Seymour Avenue on May 7.

130507172147-08-ohio-kidnapped-0507-horizontal-gallery.jpg
Cleveland Deputy Chief of Police Ed Tomba, center, speaks at a news conference to address details of the developments.

130507172150-09-ohio-kidnapped-0507-horizontal-gallery.jpg
The house where the three women were held captive in Cleveland was the home of Ariel Castro, who was arrested and is being held pending charges in the case.

130507095840-02-ohio-kidnapped-0507-horizontal-gallery.jpg
FBI agents remove evidence from the house May 7.

130507105108-03-ohio-kidnapped-0507-horizontal-gallery.jpg
A police officer stands in front of the broken front door of the house on May 7, where the kidnapped women escaped.

130507200623-charles-ramsey-horizontal-gallery.jpg
Neighbor Charles Ramsey talks to media as people congratulate him on helping the kidnapped women escape on Monday, May 6. He helped knock down the door after he heard screaming inside.


Kidnapped teens found decade later
Kidnapped teens found decade later
Kidnapped teens found decade later
Kidnapped teens found decade later
Kidnapped teens found decade later
Kidnapped teens found decade later
Photos: Kidnapped teens found decade later
Kidnapped teens found decade later
Kidnapped teens found decade later
Kidnapped teens found decade later
Kidnapped teens found decade later
Kidnapped teens found decade later
Kidnapped teens found decade later
Kidnapped teens found decade later
Kidnapped teens found decade later
Kidnapped teens found decade later
Kidnapped teens found decade later
Kidnapped teens found decade later
Kidnapped teens found decade later
Kidnapped teens found decade later
Kidnapped teens found decade later
Kidnapped teens found decade later
Kidnapped teens found decade later
Kidnapped teens found decade later
Kidnapped teens found decade later
Kidnapped teens found decade later
Kidnapped teens found decade later
Kidnapped teens found decade later
Kidnapped teens found decade later
Kidnapped teens found decade later

130709063813-amanda-berry-0709-topics.png

1
130506221059-amanda-berry-topics.png

2
130709064022-gina-dejesus-0709-topics.png

3
130506221101-georgina-gina-dejesus-topics.png

4
130709063857-michelle-knight-0709-topics.png

5
130508084006-michelle-knight-topics.jpeg

6
130801072640-knight-letter-police-topics.jpg

7
130509212846-01-ohio-kidnapped-0509-topics.jpg

8
130509213219-02-ohio-kidnapped-0509-topics.jpg

9
130509213652-03-ohio-kidnapped-0509-topics.jpg

10
130509213905-04-ohio-kidnapped-0509-topics.jpg

11
130508231744-01-ohio-kidnapped-0508-topics.jpg

12
130508232407-02-ohio-kidnapped-0508-topics.jpg

13
130508232523-03-ohio-kidnapped-0508-topics.jpg

14
130509155235-ariel-castro-mugshot-0508-topics.jpg

15
130507204138-10-ohio-kidnapped-0507-topics.jpg

16
130507204141-11-ohio-kidnapped-0507-topics.jpg

17
130507204144-12-ohio-kidnapped-0507-topics.jpg

18
130507204147-13-ohio-kidnapped-0507-topics.jpg

19
130507204149-14-ohio-kidnapped-0507-topics.jpg

20
130507204152-15-ohio-kidnapped-0507-topics.jpg

21
130507172138-04-ohio-kidnapped-0507-topics.jpg

22
130507172140-05-ohio-kidnapped-0507-topics.jpg

23
130507172142-06-ohio-kidnapped-0507-topics.jpg

24
130507172145-07-ohio-kidnapped-0507-topics.jpg

25
130507172147-08-ohio-kidnapped-0507-topics.jpg

26
130507172150-09-ohio-kidnapped-0507-topics.jpg

27
130507095840-02-ohio-kidnapped-0507-topics.jpg

28
130507105108-03-ohio-kidnapped-0507-topics.jpg

29
130507200623-charles-ramsey-topics.jpg

30



130709063813-amanda-berry-0709-horizontal-gallery.png
Photos: Kidnapped teens rescued


bttn_close.gif

130726182654-tsr-dnt-tuchman-castro-plea-deal-00000908-story-body.jpg
New details on Castro hearing
bttn_close.gif

130731193747-erin-dnt-rowlands-rapist-parental-rights-00005808-story-body.jpg
Rape victims forced to fight for custody
bttn_close.gif

130510171852-01-cleveland-0510-horizontal-gallery.jpg
Deborah Knight, the grandmother of kidnapping victim Michelle Knight, participates in a community balloon-release service in Michelle's honor on Thursday, May 9, in Cleveland. Four females were found in a home on Seymour Avenue in the Clark Fulton neighborhood on Monday. Since then, the neighborhood and the nation have wondered how they were held captive without anyone noticing sooner.

130510172457-02-cleveland-0510-horizontal-gallery.jpg
Authorities say Ariel Castro held three women -- Amanda Berry, Gina DeJesus and Michelle Knight. DNA tests confirmed that he fathered a girl born to Berry, who was among those rescued, the Ohio attorney general's office said Friday. His house, third from left, is now a crime scene.

130510171901-03-cleveland-0510-horizontal-gallery.jpg
57-year-old Ronice Dunn moved into the neighborhood in 1984. For years after Berry and DeJesus disappeared, she joined in neighborhood vigils and prayer groups for their safe return.

130510171904-04-cleveland-0510-horizontal-gallery.jpg
A building sits boarded up on Seymour Avenue. The Clark Fulton neighborhood is beset by nearly double-digit unemployment, and one in every five houses is in foreclosure.

130510171907-05-cleveland-0510-horizontal-gallery.jpg
The media set up tents near Castro's home.

130510171911-06-cleveland-0510-horizontal-gallery.jpg
Kinkel Avenue is a few blocks from Castro's home.

130510171915-07-cleveland-0510-horizontal-gallery.jpg
The house of Onil Castro's two sons, where he was staying when he was arrested on Kinkel Avenue. He and his brother Pedro were arrested along with Ariel Castro, but later were released and not charged.

130510171915-08-cleveland-0510-horizontal-gallery.jpg
"Why didn't I notice anything? What should I have been looking for?" asked Mickie Wodgik, who spent years living across the street from Castro and, it turns out, the three missing women.

130510171919-09-cleveland-0510-horizontal-gallery.jpg
Around the corner from Seymour Avenue, graffiti is written on an abandoned building.

130510171921-10-cleveland-0510-horizontal-gallery.jpg
A street view shows West 25th Street, which runs perpendicular to Seymour Avenue.

130510171924-11-cleveland-0510-horizontal-gallery.jpg
Cynthia Conor, who has lived in the same house for 38 years, often drank with Castro and and his brother Pedro, she said. Her father trained Castro for his school bus job.

130510171927-12-cleveland-0510-horizontal-gallery.jpg
A man stands on Clark Avenue in front of painted buildings.

130510171929-13-cleveland-0510-horizontal-gallery.jpg
This boarded-up building sits across the street from Castro's house.

130510171932-14-cleveland-0510-horizontal-gallery.jpg
Pastor Joe Abraham has ministered to many in this neighborhood for more than 25 years, including as the leader of Scranton Road Bible Church.

130510171937-16-cleveland-0510-horizontal-gallery.jpg
People hold balloons during a community balloon-release service in kidnapping victim Michelle Knight's honor.


The Clark Fulton neighborhood
The Clark Fulton neighborhood
The Clark Fulton neighborhood
The Clark Fulton neighborhood
The Clark Fulton neighborhood
The Clark Fulton neighborhood
The Clark Fulton neighborhood
The Clark Fulton neighborhood
The Clark Fulton neighborhood
The Clark Fulton neighborhood
The Clark Fulton neighborhood
The Clark Fulton neighborhood
The Clark Fulton neighborhood
The Clark Fulton neighborhood
The Clark Fulton neighborhood

130510171852-01-cleveland-0510-topics.jpg

1
130510172457-02-cleveland-0510-topics.jpg

2
130510171901-03-cleveland-0510-topics.jpg

3
130510171904-04-cleveland-0510-topics.jpg

4
130510171907-05-cleveland-0510-topics.jpg

5
130510171911-06-cleveland-0510-topics.jpg

6
130510171915-07-cleveland-0510-topics.jpg

7
130510171915-08-cleveland-0510-topics.jpg

8
130510171919-09-cleveland-0510-topics.jpg

9
130510171921-10-cleveland-0510-topics.jpg

10
130510171924-11-cleveland-0510-topics.jpg

11
130510171927-12-cleveland-0510-topics.jpg

12
130510171929-13-cleveland-0510-topics.jpg

13
130510171932-14-cleveland-0510-topics.jpg

14
130510171937-16-cleveland-0510-topics.jpg

15



130510171852-01-cleveland-0510-horizontal-gallery.jpg
The Clark Fulton neighborhood


Alicea said she doesn't plan on attending the sentencing with others in her family, fearing the evidence will be too graphic.
Hearing to last hours
The sentencing hearing is expected to last hours and include witness testimony and evidence, a Cuyahoga County court source, who spoke on condition of anonymity, told CNN.
Child custody rights for rapists? Most states have them
Prosecutors want to make sure there's a record going forward in case of a future appeal, should Castro want to try to get out of prison, said the source who was not authorized to speak publicly on the matter. Prosecutors also want the court and the public to understand the impact Castro's actions had on his victims and the community.
At least one of Castro's victims, Michelle Knight, will likely make an impact statement during the hearing, Alicea said. An official with direct knowledge of the investigation also said Knight intends to speak.
In a handwritten note, posted Wednesday on the Cleveland Police Community Relations Facebook page, Knight said she was overwhelmed with the support she has received from "complete strangers."
"It is comforting. Life is tough, but I'm tougher," she wrote. "Just when the caterpillar thought the world was over, she became a butterfly. Thanks."
The other two women -- Gina DeJesus and Amanda Berry -- will not be present in the court, according to the attorney representing the three women. They could make a videotaped statement, or a family member could talk on their behalf.
Ariel Castro's son: I won't visit dad in prison
Evaluating a kidnapper
Prosecutors also have submitted an evaluation of Castro's confinement and abuse of Knight, DeJesus and Berry that was compiled by acclaimed psychiatrist Frank Ochberg, considered a pioneer in trauma science.
bttn_close.gif

130729114349-nr-turner-castro-ariel-son-speaks-00001714-story-body.jpg
Son: Castro belongs in prison for life
bttn_close.gif

130726063848-01-cleveland-horizontal-gallery.jpg
On July 21, Cleveland authorities announced they had discovered the bodies of three women, later identified as Angela Deskins, from left, Shirellda Terry and Shetisha Sheeley. All three women had been reported missing.

130726064241-02-cleveland-horizontal-gallery.jpg
Michael Madison, 35, a registered sex offender, was charged in the deaths of the three women. He was arrested after investigators noticed a foul odor coming from a garage he leased and found a body inside. Police believe he killed the women over a 10-day period.

130726064417-03-cleveland-horizontal-gallery.jpg
Posters for missing women and girls can been seen all over metropolitan Cleveland's impoverished neighborhoods. The Cleveland police website lists 54 women as missing within its city limits, but a community leader said he thinks that number is actually in the hundreds.

130726064524-04-cleveland-horizontal-gallery.jpg
Christina Kleckner, 24, was last seen in Cleveland in October 2011 after an argument with her parents, according to CNN affiliate WEWS. Her father reported her missing the next day. Kleckner, a recovering drug addict with mental disabilities, was being treated for bipolar disorder and had been involved in prostitution.

130726084708-06-cleveland-horizontal-gallery.jpg
Cleveland resident Minerva Tripp vanished last year at age 41.

130507154216-ashley-summers-split-horizontal-gallery.jpg
A photo of Ashley Summers, who was last seen in the Cleveland area on July 9, 2007, beside an age-progressed rendering of her.

130510082013-christina-adkins-missing-cleveland-woman-horizontal-gallery.jpg
Christina Adkins was last seen in Cleveland in January 1995. She was 18 years old and five months pregnant when she disappeared.

130508085819-ohio-victims-split-3-horizontal-gallery.jpg
Amanda Berry emerged from captivity in May, leading to the freedom of two other missing Cleveland women: Michelle Knight, left, was abducted at age 21 in August 2002, and Gina DeJesus, center, was 14 when she disappeared in 2004. Berry, right, had gone missing at age 16 in 2003.

130509155235-ariel-castro-mugshot-0508-horizontal-gallery.jpg
Ariel Castro was charged May 8 with kidnapping the three women. He has pleaded not guilty to the 977 counts against him.

111206014545-anthony-sowell-mug-horizontal-gallery.jpg
In 2009, Cleveland police found the remains of 11 women at the home of Anthony Sowell. All had disappeared from across the city over a two-year period. Sowell is on death row.

111206053329-sowell-house-demolished-horizontal-gallery.jpg
The Cleveland home of convicted serial killer Anthony Sowell -- dubbed the "house of horrors" -- was demolished in December 2011.


Gruesome discovery in Cleveland
Suspect arrested in deaths
Cleveland's missing women
Still missing: Christina Kleckner
Still missing: Minerva Tripp
Still missing: Ashley Summers
Still missing: Christina Adkins
Missing women emerge from captivity
Cleveland's notorious serial killer
Sowell's 'house of horrors' demolished


130726063848-01-cleveland-horizontal-gallery.jpg
Photos: Cleveland's missing women


bttn_close.gif

130729230746-erin-intv-nelly-sings-to-cleveland-kidnapping-survivor-amanda-berry-00010222-story-body.jpg
Nelly: I was inspired by Berry's courage
bttn_close.gif

130507091726-bts-ramsey-saves-neighbors-00001605-story-body.jpg
Neighbor kicked in door to rescue women
The evaluation was part of the prosecution's pre-sentencing report, which has been submitted to the court.
The evaluation -- using statements, medical records, videotaped interviews and transcripts -- painted a horrifying picture of physical and emotional abuse at the hands of Castro that included brutal beatings and repeated rapes that resulted in pregnancies that he would end by punching the women in the stomach.
"He appeared to be evolving in an ever more dangerous direction, capturing younger and younger women, telling his captives he was hunting for replacements," Ochberg wrote.
Castro abducted Knight, Berry and DeJesus separately over a two-year period between 2002 and 2004, according to investigators.
Promise of a ride
In each case, Castro lured the women into his car with the promise of a ride, according to court documents submitted by Timothy McGinty, Cuyahoga County prosecuting attorney.
Castro "enticed" Knight to go inside the house, where she would be held captive in the next 11 years, with "promises of a puppy for her son."
The documents also say that Castro "serially abused (Knight, Berry and DeJesus) physically, emotionally, and sexually on a daily basis."
All three women kept diaries, with Castro's permission, providing many of the details used in the case.
Knight suffered "the longest"
The women and Berry's 6-year-old daughter were held in Castro's 1,400-square-foot home. DNA tests have confirmed that Castro is the child's father.
In the evaluation, Ochberg wrote that Knight, who was kidnapped first, suffered "the longest and most severely."
"But it was Michelle who served as doctor, nurse, midwife and pediatrician during the birth (of Berry's child). She breathed life into that infant when she wasn't breathing," he wrote.
"At other times, she interceded when Castro sought to abuse Gina, interposing herself and absorbing physical and sexual trauma. But each survivor had a will to prevail and used that will to live through the ordeal."
When freedom came
The women were freed in May after Berry shouted for help while Castro was away.
Neighbor Charles Ramsey said he heard their cries as he was sitting down to eat.
"I see this girl going nuts trying to get out of a house," he told CNN affiliate WEWS. "I go on the porch and she says, 'Help me get out. I've been in here a long time.'"
Finally free, Berry pleaded for a phone.
"Help me, I am Amanda Berry," she frantically told a 911 operator. "I've been kidnapped, and I've been missing for 10 years. And I'm here, I'm free now."
In early July, Berry, DeJesus and Knight released a YouTube video offering their thanks to all those who have helped them since they were freed. They have not faced their captor and tormentor since their rescue.
"I want to thank everyone who has helped me and my family through this entire ordeal. Everyone who has been there to support us has been a blessing," Berry said in the video. "I'm getting stronger each day."
Why so many high-profile crimes in Cleveland?
CNN's Chris Boyette, Ronni Berke, Ashley Fantz and Martin Savidge contributed to this report.

p-89EKCgBk8MZdE.gif
 
Back
Top