What if Jar Jar had been animatronic instead of cgi?

[Alistar C]

What if Jarjar had been animatronic instead?
Like a muppet!
Would The Phantom Menace have been more bearable?

 

[Will {You Violate Me?}]

Simply put, No.

The acting in that movie was terrible. It's like Liam Neeson, Ewan McGregor, and Natalie Portman all decided to be shit actors at the same time(Had to be out of spite because I know Ewan and Liam can act). And the kid that played Anakin might be top 5 worst child actors I've ever seen on film.

And hell, nothing could save Jar Jar, that's the dumbest Star Wars character EVER, I didn't think anything would top Jabba.....and then I met Jar Jar...

 

[Electric Company]

Animatronic, CGI, Claymation, Cartoon, a real person, nothing could help. He's as idiotic as the thought of Greedo shooting first.

 

[Electric Company]

Animatronic, CGI, Claymation, Cartoon, a real person, nothing could help. He's as idiotic as the thought of Greedo shooting first.

 

[Morgan R]

If it's the same voice, it would still be annoying as crap. Maybe if the voice of jar jar was Robin Williams. Now we're talkin.