Actually, bud, neither. They both have a very glaring flaw and unless you are willing to buy a vehicle that WILL NOT last more than 20,000 miles I suggest that you turn your head and look the other way. I promise, that car is crap!!!! The transmission of my 08 dropped out at 24,500 miles, wouldn't even go into reverse. I traded it for an 09 and the difference in cost, guess what, 20,000 miles later, NO TRANSMISSION. They were both automatics so it was no fault of my own. Buy a jeep!