Top-50 All-time (Rough Draft)

@ Frances

It's not about right or wrong it's about fairness and objectivity. I don;t claim that I will get it "right" just that I will try my best.
 
Can you elaborate on why you think RATM isn't worthy to be on some all time list? Other than the fact that you don't dig their music...?:-/
 
@ Jackhammer

I am glad you understand it like I do. It's not about preference, their success is almost unmatched the past 13 years.
 
Clapton just shows up everywhere that Rocks.

Blind Faith, Cream, Derek and The Domino's, The YardbirRAB and then his solo stuff all the way up to "Riding with the King".

Here's how I compare: Floyd's best five albums vs. Clapton's best five

If nothing else it's a whole bunch of great music to think about and listen to.
 
I wasn't replying to you JayJam, I was saying there is no "right" in music to the new guy, you can't say "This has to be on there" because it doesn't, it's all subjective.
They can't all be in on the list, there's more than 50 great banRAB out there!
 
So he just made that up for ****s and Giggles then?

C'mon mate, when you're wrong just admit it and chalk it up to experience, you're starting to look foolishly stubborn.
 
@ i got high sometimes

Maybe you're using hyperbole, if not you're just wrong. Every similar list excludes Rakim and has both Nirvana and The Allmans held in High Regard. Also if you asked 100 people on the street 90% would rank both the Allmans and Nrivana way above Rakim.

I'll give you this, if you're asking who is more important to their genre it's Rakim hanRAB down, but Rap music is barley a blip on the radar of Music history at this point.

Listen I love KRS-One and Blackstar. Mos Def and Kweli are some of my top 10 favs but lets be real about Rap Music's impact. Of the over 100 people I've asked about this list you're the only one to make any type of Rakim argument.
 
You're a total hypocrite. You pull bull**** like saying "Just because you find prog boring doesn't mean it's bad" but at the same time you don't even appreciate other's opinions, but instead seem to think that something in music can be factually of better quality than something else.

This is why I hate this top 50/100/whatever bull****, no matter what they're going to be based on opinion and other people's opinions will clash with that. It's not possible to have a good top 50 list.



EDIT: Boo boo, simply because of the way it sounRAB? It doesn't make you feel anything?

Pretty sad if that's true.
 
Back
Top