No need for an attorney. That's the point of small claims court. I doubt the police didn't take a report (that would be VERY unusual). In small claims court, you have to prove that its more likely than not that your version of the facts is correct. Judges are smart enough to know that one's friends are likely to bend the truth to help their friend. You might want to talk to an attorney for some advice if you know a lawyer, I don't think its worth hiring one - it will likely cost more than the deductible. Also, the judge may toss the case because the facts are still in dispute by the insurance company and there no determination by the police department.