Should I cull/kill my sick fish?

Sunshine

New member
How big is the tank? I would separate them into 2 separate tanks(even if it means buying one) Does the pleco have fin rot to? He should be in at least a 55 gallon tank.
 
I recently took in a freshwater tank with one pleco and 27 guppies in it. When I picked it up, the water quality was atrocious....it wasn't full, and the water itself was a carmel-brown color. Needless to say, the guppies were all nearly colorless when I got them.

I've had the tank completely cleaned, and it's been up and running with the fish for about 2 weeks now. The guppies have all gained a tremendous amount of color back, and none have died since the initial transportation.

My problem is this:

some of the fish have fin rot, and there are several who are deformed. I thought at first that the deformed fish were just the result of growing up in a bad tank. However, I'm now led to believe that they have developed fish tuberculosis!!
Given the fact that my tank is already a bit heavily stocked, and both of these diseases can be fatal, should I just remove the fish with TB in order to save the rest of the aquarium instead of trying to treat the whole tank? I don't have the space to set up another "treatment tank", so if I treat one, I treat them all.

Do I cull the infected fish or no?
it is a 25 gallon...which is why i'm seriously considering just taking a few out.

again, I don't have space for another tank!
the pleco is actually rather healthy! he was a little lethargic at first, but some algea tablets and greenery have really got him going lol
 
don't kill them, separate them into different tanks. or buying a divider for the fish that can be put in a smallish space.buy bowls for the time and try buying conditioner and treating them, if none of that work kill the worst ones and have hope in the not to bad ones.
 
Back
Top