It depends on what type of individual you are. Why did you go to law school? To help others, to right wrongs or to have a healthy salary? What are your motivations? I personally would go to the tiny town as they are probably in more of a need of good counsel than a big city, where there are too many attorneys. One on each corner. And for the record, it is not because of the money for me. People in small towns have legal problems also, just like everybody else. But most attorneys go for the big bucks and settle into the big city and leave the small towns to fend for themselves. The money would be nice, but more important, you would be kind of a hero to help people with their problems and that would be super, more rewarding than the salary. At least for me. You have to decide what type of person you are.