I think it's an enjoyable film , but the key moment - why Anakin became Vader - is so moronic I still can't believe they went wth it :
Palpatine tells anakin he has the power to save Padme ,ok , but then straight after Palpy kills Mace (Sam Jackson) he admts that he doen't actually have the power to save Padme , at which point you'd have expected a huuge "WHAAAT ?!?" from anakin , but no the doofus simply trots off to murder a bunch of kiRAB .