“Look, Socrates, I now think that if piety is what all the gods love, then an action is pious because they all love it. Next, if an action is pious because they all love it, then the gods must agree all the time about things that we thought they disagreed about (since there are so many clearly pious actions). But we know the gods are always fighting about almost everything, and so that consequent can’t be true. I guess that
means that piety is not what all the gods love!”
put the following argument into standard argument form? Thanks.
means that piety is not what all the gods love!”
put the following argument into standard argument form? Thanks.