P1i or S710

So here's my question,
Both phones are generally small... and are fairly similar in the fact they both have Wifi and both have keyboards(Requirements for me).

So my question boils down to this... which phone should I go for?

I mean 3.2 camera is pretty tempting but the S710 is quad-band and I'm stuck in Montreal with really crappy reception.

I used to have an 802 Sharp and it was pretty much light years ahead of anything available but I had the worst reception ever. I'd like to prevent myself from doing the same mistake twice.

How's the reception on the P1 like? And I'm not to concerned about the OS... since I've used both UIQ and Mobile 6 before.

Any alternative phones... small, keyboard and wifi?
 
Nokia e61i ... I'm testing one out now for a review. It looks like something from 1967, but works really, really well. Edge, WiFi, camera, and a great keyboard. Only issue so far is it's not super comfy (for me) on voice calls ... but it's really thin and pocketable.
 
Back
Top