S
scrappynme
Guest
OK, I'm confused...In the film and musical versions of "The Phantom of the Opera", it is said that Madame Giry met the Phantom in childhood at a freak show, and she brought him to the opera house to live and hide.
But I read on Wikipedia (and I don't know if Wikipedia is always right) that the Phantom was actually INVOLVED in the building of the opera house, and Giry didn't meet him until she was an adult, the opera house was built, and the Phantom had lived there for a while.
Is Wikipedia exactly right and reliable of a website?
I WAS reading about the book, Wikipedia was TALKING about the book. Can people give me answers, please, about when Giry met Erik? No more answers about which website to use, please. I just want info on the story.
Useful info, I've read the book a long time ago.
But I read on Wikipedia (and I don't know if Wikipedia is always right) that the Phantom was actually INVOLVED in the building of the opera house, and Giry didn't meet him until she was an adult, the opera house was built, and the Phantom had lived there for a while.
Is Wikipedia exactly right and reliable of a website?
I WAS reading about the book, Wikipedia was TALKING about the book. Can people give me answers, please, about when Giry met Erik? No more answers about which website to use, please. I just want info on the story.
Useful info, I've read the book a long time ago.