Left-handedness being poorly represented

Kunmui

New member
Has anyone noticed that whenever a left-handed character is represented in animation, they are usually geeky (Doug Funnie), obnoxious (Bart Simpson), evil (Sasuke Uchiha), or just weird (Haruko Haruhara)?

Maybe I'm being too sensitive, but I find it a little offensive that lefties are hardly ever portrayed as regular people or at least with more positive qualities.
 
Who said left-handed people are normal? I'm left-handed, and I'm one weird hombre.

And what was so bad about Doug? He was about as normal a person as you could ever find, a true everyman.

Bart Simpson is one of the most popular cartoon characters ever created. I think he's a great example of the left-handed spirit.

Sasuke... well there is always one bad apple in the bunch. Women (real women) often find him attractive however.

Haruko was just plain odd, but her character was well balanced with both positive and negative traits. There was nothing offensive about her.

Don't get so high-string about it. Just remember, we lefties are the only people truly right in the head. :p
 
I didn't mean that Doug being a bit of a geek was a bad thing. I'm saying that a left-handed character will more often than not be geeky or possess the other traits I mentioned. It's not necessarily a bad thing, but since lefties make up such a small portion of the human population, it's like they're saying most of us are like that.
 
Sounds like a bit of a stretch to me - for the record, I'm left-handed (and consider myself to be relatively normal) and I'm certainly not offended. Fact is, anytime you have a minority, they are, by definition, an oddity, and I dare say they then deserve to be treated as such in their fictional portrayels.

And it's not like being a lefty is really much of a choice, and I have HUGE issues with minorities who are "proud" of something they can't control. You can be proud to be a volunteer at an animal shelter because it's a choice you've made to do so... but, conversely, you really shouldn't be proud of being a lefty if you haven't expressly made the choice to be one, and if you shouldn't have pride in something, then you really have no reason to be offended or elated by the way lefties are portrayed.
 
Obviously you lack a sense of ethnicism (if thats a word).



Err, rather subjective opinion but hey, we are all entitled to our opinions but I'm not surprised that is offended Ahiru-kun.

But if we had a left handed jock someone would say they were offend because every lefthanded person was being shown as a jock.

Doug was not really geeky at all. Not one of the popular kids at school but that doesn't mean he is a geek. and nothing wrong with being a geek.
 
Maybe, but then, everybody comes from SOMEWHERE and has SOME kind of ancestry, and I think as an American with German roots on one side of my family I still have some qualification to put myself in the place of someone with ethnicity. And, either way, I just find it hard to be proud of my ancestry. Not to say I'm ashamed, either. I don't think either feelings are really applicable to something that isn't a conscious choice. You can find appreciation or dislike for things in your heritage or ethnicity, but to be proud or ashamed as though its somehow a reflection on you or your own abilities doesn't seem right to me.

I mean, putting aside my German heritage on the one side of the family or left-handedness, as an American there are things in my country's past that I appreciate (such as relative religious freedom) and others that I absolutely despise (such as slavery), but ultimately I don't feel proud of the former just because some ancestor from one side of the family that I may or may not be related to had some part, and on the same note I don't feel personally ashamed for the latter - I have my own personal moral values that tell me that slavery is wrong and freedom of religion is right, and I don't need any ancestors to tell me that.

And I don't just mean race, either - in fact, that wasn't really even what was in my mind when I was typing my original post, although it still applies. What I had in mind was the sheer number of people I've talked to through the years that are proud because their dad was a police officer or a doctor and saved lives, even though it bears no reflection on that person himself and said person had NO say in whether his dad was a doctor or a rapist. And society really puts out an inconsistent message here, anyway - if your parents are doctors, we expect that you SHOULD somehow be proud of that, but if they were murderers, we say that you SHOULDN'T be personally ashamed or think that it reflects who you are.

Another example would be a girl that was on America's Got Talent last night - she was a contortionist who was clearly born with the ability to move her body in all sorts of different ways most people physically would be unable to - and, naturally, her parents and the judges say she should be proud of her abilities. So, by that logic, I should be ashamed that I don't have such abilities. I should hold my head low everyday of my life simply because my body limits my movements to certain directions. Again, this speaks to my opinion (which, as you stated, you're welcome to disagree with) that you really can't have pride without also having shame, and therefore it's better to have neither if it's something you have no control over.

But, that's as far as I'll go with this - it's making me seem racist or uncultured and I really don't think that I'm either - I just have a sense of apathy for something that society tells us most of the time to be exuberant over, and to most people that apathy appears racist or uncultured.
 
Bart Simpson's left-handed?...I knew Flanders and alot of the Simpsons cast was,but I never noticed Bart was...

Anyway,to be honest,unless it's mentioned(Doug,The Simpsons),I never notice whether characters are right or left-handed....it's just never been a big deal to me (for the record,though,I'm left-handed myself)....

and,to add to the list,here's a couple video game characters I know are left-handed(didn't notice until it was pointed out to me)...

Link (Legend of Zelda series)

Sephiroth (Final Fantasy VII series,Kingdom Hearts series)...
 
They observed it on one of the "Simpsons" DVD commentaries. Yeardley Smith asks if Bart's left-handedness is Matt Groening's "tribute" (apparently meaning to say "reference") to himself, and Matt sarcastically responds "Yeah, that's my 'tribute' to me."

Leave it to Yeardley to always ask the most bizarre questions on these things...
 
I'm not surprised with this portrayal. Lefties are the sinister race.

I'm kidding, but that's not that far from what people thought about lefties in the past. The origin of the word sinister is the Latin word for left. The left was definitely associated with badness and wrongness through much of the world while right symbolized, well, right. It wasn't that long ago that teachers would force left-handed students to try to be right-handed.

My point, left-handedness still, right or wrong, has associations with oddness and when animators are coming up with a character with unusual traits to reinforce how unusual the character is, left-handedness might be something they go to. If they're thinking hard enough about it to keep track of the fact that a character has to be left-handed all the time and animated differently than most of the others, then there's probably a reason why they made that choice.
 
I would expect most characters who are evil to be left-handed, just for the historical association alone. In fact It's a good bet that a character who is overtly left-handed is being hinted at as being evil, sinister, a weirdo, etc.
 
Francine Smith from American Dad is left-handed.

But because she was beaten by a nun while she was little for writing with her left hand, she forgot how to.
 
Back
Top