If you were judge a story solely on the first page and this was what you read...

...would, you want to read the rest? I am mainly looking for people who actually know what they were talking about to answer. I don't an answer that just says "oh it's really good, I like it a lot" I want an answer that can really give me feedback. What so good about it, or what needs work, etc.
I'm looking to see what you think of how well it is written, and about the story itself. From this it doesn't really say much, but that is what I'm going for. A story about the mundane life, lol. I really feel that is more artistic than anything becuase people put so much effort write stories about life and make full of glamorize it and over dramatize it. I wanted to do something different. So I am writing it through the view point of an ordinary person living his ordinary life facing ordinary problems. Something much more realistic than a lot of stories out there. Hope you like it.
Also I can't seem to dent the paragraph, sorry about that lol And it is a bit rough, not quite the worthy to be published yet. Just starting this story out, so keep that in mind.
--------------------------------------

There was something about that night that seemed different. Maybe it was the shift in the wind, or the sudden lack of warmness in the November Air. Maybe it was the way the day started; it could have been something I ate. It could have been the way Naomi just walked away without a word or reason. It could have been the way she just yelled; the way the tears streaked down her soft pale complexion as she uttered each hateful sentence. It could have been the way if felt when her palm struck my check. It could have been the way my heart stopped the moment her back was to me.

I felt so dead. I don’t know why, I never really knew her. It wasn’t as if the six month relationship was going anywhere. I should have guessed it the moment I walked in on her crying in the corner of our studio apartment on Telegraph Avenue. She had her head against the bare corner and her arms wrapped around her legs. The way her hair fell partly against her face, God she was beautiful, sad, but nonetheless beautiful. There was something in the way she needed me, or thought she did. As I came closer she screamed stop. An inch of movement incited another stop. She kept on uttering to herself, but I couldn’t make out a legible word. So I just walked over the where I dropped my bag and closed the door. I placed it atop of our “dining” table. It was this old beaten up table we saved from being trashed. It was early to mid August, we have just come back from a brief lunch and the table was lopsided near the garbage bin outside the complex. Someone must of saw it fit to throw a perfectly good table. So we decided to take it in. A leg was missing, and there were a couple of dents on the surface, but still perfectly useable. Since we didn’t have a fancy house with a fancy formal dining room to a put a real dining table in, we decided to call our new friend our “dining” table. I shifted through my bag and pulled a flat brown paper bag and brought to the far right corner where we placed the old record player we bought at a garage sale. I pulled out an Indian Summer record I just found earlier that day. I was going to surprise her. I played the record and made a pot a coffee. I pulled a chair out and sat and sipped my coffee quietly as the record play through. Halfway through she got up, poured herself a cup and pulled out the other chair. We didn’t talk, we just listened. By the time the record played the last song she had fallen asleep. Her shallow breathing sounded like music, if only you heard. It was hard to not smile as I carried her to the bed.
 
As for your plot, I don't think it would really interest me. "Everyday life" stories tend to bore me.

Anyway, here are some possible corrections...

I think the second paragraph needs to be split into more paragraphs. As it is, it just seems to ramble on.

"November Air"-- "air" shouldn't be capitalized.

You might want to change some of those "It could have been the way"s in the first paragraph. Give your sentences more variation. I know you purposely made the beginnings the same for effect. I just think you overdid it a little. Maybe change the last couple sentences in that paragraph.

"Six month relationship" should be "six-month relationship."

The second sentence of the second paragraph is rather lengthy...you might want to reword it or split it up somehow. "...her face, God she was..." should have a dash, not a comma. Or you could reword it entirely.

When you tell how she told him to stop, "stop" should be in quotes. Either that, or write, "she screamed at me to stop" instead.

"Uttering" should be "muttering." "We have just come back from..." should be "we had just come back from."

"Someone must of saw it fit to throw a perfectly good table." Lol, I'm pretty sure you just forgot to type the word "out" after throw.

In "I shifted through my bag," the word "shifted" could be replaced by "dug" or "searched."

"...and pulled a flat brown paper..." Again, I think you just forgot the word "out." "Halfway through she..." needs a comma after "through."

There were probably a few other minor errors I missed (missing commas and the like) but those are what stood out.
 
You mentioned the season nice and early (Japanese style) and Naomi is a Japanese girls name. Is that where the story's going?

Using "could have" 5 times in a paragraph is a bit too much. Stick to the rule of 3s.

There's only one metaphor "I felt dead" and one simile "breathing sounded like music" and the rest is solid, dry description full of pronouns.

And when I'm deciding whether I like it or not you're talking about a table. Is the table a metaphor for the relationship? You need to set up more context then 'it's November and a Naomi left you' because that's all I got out of it.

The beginning of VS Naipaul's "A House for Mr Biswas" is how to set up mundaneness. The prologue talks about his house and debts.

After reading your opening I would be flicking head to see when Chapter 2 starts.
 
The first sentence was hooking, but I think it could have been stronger.

In the first paragraph you keep saying 'it could have been', I think that's good, but you need to finish it off with a short and snappy sentence. One that's adds tension. Otherwise it doesn't seem finished, well not in my opinion anyways.

Okay...what is the genre for this story? Because whatever it is, you definately need more tension to your story.
 
Back
Top