help me settle a debate between my wife and I?

M

Mick

New member
Guys would you consider a 5"8 woman who weighs 125 pounds to be:

a)too skinny
b)skinny
c)average
d)overweight

Women can answer too but if you think your opinion would be different to a male opinion could you also put what you think a man's opinion would be too..

Thanks
This question isn't about my wife, its a generalized discussion the measurements are an example
 
My husband says too skinny.

I am 5'8" and weighed more than that in high school as a cross country runner (I think I weighed 140 then). I used to run 5 - 12 miles a day back then. 125 is very skinny for that height.
 
Too skinny, or at least, skinny. It's definitely not average.

I am 5'8" and used to weigh 127 (before kids) and wore an XS (0/2). My husband looks at pictures of me back then (before we met) and says I was "too thin".
 
I am a female, and I think that that would be b: I also think that it depends on how she is proportioned. My husband is right here, and he is saying too skinny, or skinny, but would still look good to add some weight.
 
Either B or C. But my advice is to avoid these type of questions. A woman asking the question is looking for what others think and a guy is looking for what he thinks. Both are subjective. Besides, if you want a happy marriage then the correct answer is whatever she says it is.
 
I'm a Woman who is also 5'8 and Hunny .. its too thin.. sorry but it is.. I'm not certain but I think your BMI probably shows that as well
 
Back
Top