I just hate it, I hate how it looks mostly, and I hate the idea behind it. That its like cheating, like even if they do cool things nowadays, like those sony bravia commercials with the rabbits and bouncyballs, people say; its CGI..... Its kind of ruined the whole idea behind filmmaking hasnt it ?
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Has CGI ruined film ?
- Thread starter Bobby Bob
- Start date
whycantigetagoodnickname
New member
There has been a bad patch where graphics got in the way of the story - people were going to see the pictures rather than the story. However now that everyone has computer effects in their films the good ones of the future are going to have to tell us something apart from "Hey we can get a computer to do this, isn't that cool" - cool but to be honest not that entertaining for 2 1/2 hours.
The best films though at the moment will always use real camera, real props and real actors and actresses
The best films though at the moment will always use real camera, real props and real actors and actresses
In many ways, yes, in many ways, no. It's a tough question to answer, since when CGI was first mastered, many people were mind-blown and shocked at how realistic elements, such as Animals and Sci-Fi creatures were brought to life, it was at the time, amazing. But after almost 20 years of films being made with CGI effects, it has become a stereotype and has been used and used so much, it has become tiring. Many people now aren't surprised as much with CGI, since it has become a usual thing, and some people now wish film makers stopped using CGI and made films the way they used to be made like.
I don't hate it, but to make it work you have to invest serious amounts of money and uses alot of computer power to render shades, textures and lighting successfully.
If filmmakers don't have the money and still use CGI, it looks far worse than if they'd used foam rubber, prosthetics and modelling, because you can light and interact with physical things easily.
A lot of modern cheap scifi/horrors have no appeal because of the CGI, whereas in the 50's -80's, it was all stop-motion animation and solid, physical stuff the actors could see and interact with, and they had quite a fanbase, because a lot of care was put in for little money, and the final product looked good enough to suspend some disbelief. When things aren't rendered well, they look like 2-D patterns interacting with 3-d naturally lit and textured actors and sets. Another thing with CGI is eyelines - Even in Phantom Menace, when Obi wan and Qui gon land on Nabbo and meet Ja Jar, look at where Ewan Mcgregor's eyes are looking -about 3 inches above Jar Jar's head.
Had that been an actor in a latex mask, the eyeline would be correct, because Ewan would see him. Liam Neeson threatened to never work in films again after the Phantom Menace.
That's why I like The Expendables. Very little CGI was used.
If filmmakers don't have the money and still use CGI, it looks far worse than if they'd used foam rubber, prosthetics and modelling, because you can light and interact with physical things easily.
A lot of modern cheap scifi/horrors have no appeal because of the CGI, whereas in the 50's -80's, it was all stop-motion animation and solid, physical stuff the actors could see and interact with, and they had quite a fanbase, because a lot of care was put in for little money, and the final product looked good enough to suspend some disbelief. When things aren't rendered well, they look like 2-D patterns interacting with 3-d naturally lit and textured actors and sets. Another thing with CGI is eyelines - Even in Phantom Menace, when Obi wan and Qui gon land on Nabbo and meet Ja Jar, look at where Ewan Mcgregor's eyes are looking -about 3 inches above Jar Jar's head.
Had that been an actor in a latex mask, the eyeline would be correct, because Ewan would see him. Liam Neeson threatened to never work in films again after the Phantom Menace.
That's why I like The Expendables. Very little CGI was used.