Definitely not, i dont care if my boyfriend can bench 300 pounds, or can fight the longest or can run the fastest, or has the deepest voice or is the tallest. I look for someone who can make me happy, i've dated not many, but a variety of guys, one, a short stubby strong boy from my town, two, a tall 6'4 boy from arizona (I'm in canada by the way) with no muscles what so ever, i can beat him up and i'm 5'4 and 120 pounds. It shouldnt matter to you what you look like to other girls, cus i can tell you right now looks only go so far with the right girls. you dont want to be with someone who just cares about how much swag you got going on. yeah it's a bonus, but that's all it should be taken as. that's my opinion.
But if i must answer you question, i vote pretty looking guys, they look sweeter like they will care more, and rugged looking guys look like they'll flake on you because they can get whatever girls they want, just by looking that way.
