I was surprised in the sense of at least Natalie Portman for BSA, Drama and Zach Braff for BD, Drama...
However, the film is not as "life alterning" as a lot of people claim. It is a good film, but as I stated earlier, it is mostly for generation-Y and deals with some pretty cliche stuff (going off anti-depression medication; the whacky girlfriend; the domineering dad, etc) when you get right down to it.
One can say all films deal with cliched subjects.... True... But with Garden State it is like people are championing this film like it is some truly original, Earth-shatting film making when all it is a decent first effort by Zach Braff and the cast and wasn't funded by a mainstream, Hollywood studio is all.