If it is between just the ones you have listed, I would say Toyota overall. My favorite american car manufacturer is Ford, in my opinion they have the most number of reliable vehicles, but Chevy makes my all-time favorite car, the Corvette, also the duramax diesel pickups are great.
But still Toyota would be my favorite out of your list, but if you were including all manufacturers I would pick Honda.
So Toyota, or Honda if you can include Honda.