fantasy baseball which team is better _head to head league?

[jason l]

this team has three great players
1. (2) Albert Pujols
2. (19) Tim Lincecum
3. (22) Johan Santana
4. (39) Carlos Quentin
5. (42) Matt Kemp
6. (59) Curtis Granderson
7. (62) Joe Nathan
8. (79) Garrett Atkins
9. (82) Mariano Rivera
10. (99) Michael Young
11. (102) Carlos Zambrano
12. (119) Howie Kendrick
13. (122) Matt Wieters
14. (139) Matt Garza
15. (142) Chris Young
16. (159) Ryan Zimmerman
17. (162) James Loney
18. (179) Justin Upton
19. (182) Aaron Harang
20. (199) John Danks
21. (202) Orlando Cabrera
22. (219) Mike Napoli
23. (222) Joey Devine
24. (239) Hideki Matsui
25. (242) Plácido Polanco
but i feel this team has more depth
1. (5) Ryan Braun
2. (16) Dustin Pedroia
3. (25) Prince Fielder
4. (36) CC Sabathia
5. (45) Brian McCann
6. (56) Rafael Furcal
7. (65) Francisco Liriano
8. (76) Cliff Lee
9. (85) Brad Lidge
10. (96) Torii Hunter
11. (105) Yovani Gallardo
12. (116) Mike Aviles
13. (125) Lastings Milledge
14. (136) Brian Fuentes
15. (145) Adam Wainwright
16. (156) Jorge Cantú
17. (165) Max Scherzer
18. (176) Heath Bell
19. (185) Alex Gordon
20. (196) John Maine
21. (205) Denard Span
22. (216) Joe Saunders
23. (225) Coco Crisp
24. (236) Paul Maholm
25. (245) Chris Pérez
what do you think which one is better