It seems that he was just pissed off that Yu Yu Hakusho beat NGE in terms of popularity (since it was considerably more popular a few years ago on Toonami, than it is now). I can understand if people feel that way, but just like people were saying on that thread, there is no reason to whine about it. Besides, if we did a top 25 list right now, I guarentee that YYH wouldn't even make it into the top 20, now, and would be lucky if it even made it onto the list, at all.
I guess I can see why people were calling it overrated, back then, but I do feel that YYH is misunderstood by so many people. It has so much more to it than just the battles, and the Dark Tournament and Chapter Black arcs had brilliant story-telling, IMO. Of course, people who aren't too fond of shounen will say that YYH and RK do not belong in the top 5, and since it doesn't have the exact same type of appeal as most other shounen (at least to me and a few others), quite a few people who are fans of shounen anime wouldn't see it as being that great, or at least wouldn't put it above the more popular shounen titles like DBZ.
Overall, I personally think that YYH has now become kind of underrated, these days. But maybe that's just me.
Well, sorry for going off-topic, again.
Back on topic:
I forgot to recommend this on my original post in this thread, but Ouran High School Host Club is also a pretty good anime to start out with. I myself haven't finished it, but from what I have seen of the first 14 episodes, its one of the few anime that have truly managed to make me laugh. And, as anyone can guess, its not action oriented at all. Whenever someone hits someone else in that series, its purely in comical manner and style. So I don't really see how anyone can go wrong with this series, especially when watching the English dub.