Holy Moly, rumrunner - that's outrageous! One more reason not to live in MA (among many others I keep telling my brother!). I live in the DFW area, have full coverage on 2011 RKC, wife's 09 XL1200C, and my 99 XL1200S. Total for all three is $549 per year through Foremost.
Funny thing is when I added the wife's scoot to the policy, total premium only went up $48 per year because the multi-bike discounts on the other two went up now that there were three bikes instead of two!