That's not a rant.
It is the single most cohesive argument I've ever seen comparing these two products - and personally I HOPE it was directed toward me, because they're all the SAME EXACT differences I saw and there's the quandry I'm in. Right down to the gorillas. I was going to mail TODAY the payment for Datebk5, and after the weekend DELETE agendus, keeping the icons, and DO THE SAME EXACT THING!!
My personal debate within myself was whether to ABANDON Agendus and "put up" with DB5 in the hopes of stability and hopefully "similar" looks. I'm into "visual quickness," so I can get an idea of what I'm doing when the T3's on the car seat. CRAMPED is accurate -- and no good. I was thinking yesterday afternoon about posting screen shots to ask if ANYONE can do this with Datebk5 - and then yours popped up this morning!!
I tried Datebk5 THREE TIMES before and also went through the "@@@" purging -- and I didn't have the patience you did to give Datebk5 the grace period you did -- it's huge pain. Ended up with a corrupted calendar DB (due to remnants from SOMETHING) and remember you offering me advice on it.
I agree with EVERY SINGLE POINT YOU MADE above, and the comparison regarding "meeting creation" taps was illuminating to say the least. More like frightening. I remember during previous "trials" thinking "man, you've got to spend an AGE making sure everything's ticked off correctly;" I seldom have to pick an icon using Vivid Agenda or templates, for example.
I've read an awful lot on this forum and others about DB5 vs Agendus - you being a contributor among others -- but the one above should be framed in every PalmOS owner's office and made a sticky on this forum. It's brilliant, frankly.
A while back I tried, in simple blunt ANGER, several other calendar/datebook apps while frosted at Iambic's crappy 8.00/01/02/03/04/05 "Oh we got it sorta right in 8.06 but it'll cost ya" attitude, and the result of trying to switch was a NIGHTMARE. I paid the upgrade to V8 PRO and it's working fine for me. Now of course, 2 months later . . . it's the $9.95 thing and judging from their beta page nothing is remotely "final" yet. That's the only part where we "differ;" V9 is too close to V8 which was never really fixed, and the upgrade fee is a sticking point despite wanting some V9 features. If it comes down to it I guess we can all be bigshots for a $10 bill ONCE; it's the fact that it's "$39 + 10 +10 +10 never ending" that irritates people, me included. If they update and "improve" something, they should make sure it works. some of you might enjoy reading this link:
http://support.iambic.com/forum/showthread.php?t=11765
But talk about getting to the meat of it . . . you certainly did and I appreciate it very much. It's helped me "decide," and spared me yet another "@@@" nightmare had I not been able to deal with Datebk5.