About Gaza--should European Jews be put in camps?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Billy Bobb
  • Start date Start date
B

Billy Bobb

Guest
For their own safety, as has been suggested? There have been an increasing number of attacks on Jewish people, particularly in Europe, over the Gaza operations by Israel. Do you think it's a good idea?
 
I think moderate jews should openly voice their opposition on Israeli policy of murdering Palestinians.
 
Actually, you suggested it yesterday :)
http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index;_ylt=ApxyswFjuYaU0bcxkFXMcJHty6IX;_ylv=3?qid=20090115073844AAu8pIe&show=7#profile-info-ieZVL4fzaa

My answer remains the same (except for minor grammatical changes)
No, it was wrong during WWII and it would be wrong now. By the same logic, Palestinians shouldn't be held in refugee camps within Gaza "for their safety", under siege with Israel's blockading the borders and cutting of the supply lines for food, water and medical supplies. Strange how that lesson wasn't learned from the concentration camps and Warsaw ghettos of the WWII era. The hypocrisy of it is amazing.

<edit>
Sabrina... I agree and some are protesting!
http://www.democracynow.org/2009/1/16/headlines
(about halfway down the page)
 
No - may be British Liberalism should be, as I see no one defending her!

Edit - and she is attacked on all sides
 
I think that innocent Jews, although an extreme rarity, should'nt be subjected to any bad treatment. However, Israel has no right to exist legally.
 
Back
Top